From a3aa7637e0bcf5419ef744ad514e07eeb198b1e5 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Benjamin Mako Hill Date: Tue, 11 Jun 2019 17:58:39 -0700 Subject: [PATCH] added CSCW 2016 paper on remixing and learning --- .../2016-remixing_learning/README.txt | 7 + ...emixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.pdf | Bin 0 -> 76782 bytes ...emixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.tex | 151 ++++++++++ ...ixing_learning-CSCW2016-reviews_round1.txt | 265 ++++++++++++++++++ 4 files changed, 423 insertions(+) create mode 100644 cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/README.txt create mode 100644 cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.pdf create mode 100644 cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.tex create mode 100644 cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-reviews_round1.txt diff --git a/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/README.txt b/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/README.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..3f5a313 --- /dev/null +++ b/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/README.txt @@ -0,0 +1,7 @@ +Material for: + +Dasgupta, Sayamindu, William Hale, Andrés Monroy-Hernández, and Benjamin Mako +Hill. 2016. “Remixing As a Pathway to Computational Thinking.” In Proceedings +of the 19th ACM Conference on Computer-Supported Cooperative Work & Social +Computing (CSCW ’16), 1438–1449. New York, New York: ACM. +https://doi.org/10.1145/2818048.2819984 diff --git a/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.pdf b/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.pdf new file mode 100644 index 0000000000000000000000000000000000000000..c7e6ad249e9c0a0e097a2e700d2a1e0c6af30274 GIT binary patch literal 76782 zcmb5WV|1n8()JtMwr$%+$4E>BO}b#I9GhYosfZNLGHK7BfTNOep})9nJ|6ARv>n#}OdC?U=lR{~V#`rhuy>sH z;+ZudSKO?7VP_EWcsuR;xlZn0SaQclnNR;z5Pv-sIp6YmHO}usB@0(h;}R?BQo5I5 z>&yR`>OO}Ik;`r3%el6LtOb%vwGJVL!d(RCoI_qZP%tJy+~ip~FC0I{iC=j)-~Yi_ z;ee7G1rv3bH0-fLP5`DPfb}$;e^MDL_iav_+|tz4r~tSDgKyMbAA7Zj>>K~iizi-U zozWs)zdc`eygAp@#w6t=$J6NKq>-+M9*bhsDQZtC zrV8QIV0%>yODt_HCfwRJBwUQ_vf7FrE?oZ4IrZF5xCTmp=0PvPv|c5^iG#19b*7cyx5l(Uy{t5J~yr4fvg*%em6NzCJW64 zJ5>B*Y*TvVd721aWxIs#9#p&gZCG^%`UL|)EnOOQCeR6fnd0tm#l~PTrbNxOSqJH6 zZomhOI*0ExN1WEYw%W#e$Y>8kkD$SQuANI5;lI#Crt}a3n4*!LM23lf3RLDtc2&9r zfu5zylI4t=nidO)MfFo&oA2~9gf_X?5JBCCSJUR}f*)p1?F_h(Sh6|Va&Y}Ve`(Pg z1FFMx8WP_{Mfwg1XK2qNv2$hKjRX99%MF|YLlwMQQ?gCzfKb6bL6;=#%f4t#6PzzCbaB}a*qd88euU=oGhh9zz$kHX6SPPL1ynEISDt#eB z*ix*I!HE@p?_n`%Q9LmS1WYPG-Zpp&d!8;j0*OM9S-RQq0m$&VYlkg>qgT!YNoeyD zdqb*CV3ha=dj+aqsyOv}9S=)T7N^i$+K@#hoCuHPH#nZ`fR}6+@&?Xyv7JNF1ywoC zG?-wu3`56L#&wuADV8ST`N=Bt&j2Q$d1qHiZ;1$;wyc1k-)*%ORA$9J18RkME0C}S zg#9nT$m|+!Cr&*rq$Re}z|jRD&zmSd0i9c-inR2XEdro46F?}Er`$!Z4FZ83q~8VM&UPC*gIb3vVKXK_LrJuP)!pNaZ=;pdtEnuKMS{VD(O?F6w`ywAm?^MW=C)1NrT5=cwEo%?^$*0x{V1CLy$A9 zvJkJ;p5#xrn5j01mk47lV_oC1wZuoDv}!IXL@x2fTwwr5FPXs8sl@x&wWG)OoFo#mSwMkf% zegZ}+MFHzW(}$xY^3c&lW07kK+i74C5^j3A9~o>wmJ3Z0F$OvBCY1w z?yWpJRZmfOv~GyadLX~^*;QTzjv|BZ%wooL(hm*)tIFGfSL2mJe0sx_a2fFxh1{vE*6C8u^qy-){#=2T2#GOXD-cgr#V91?0WaB{8ub@vj4 zb2NUCQ0_Ok-ka1S-ijGwlz;-Vq+e>)8C1Uj1Wfc#u}V1FOE@}7Z|&UrBKjcZa7KQZ zIzF^)k!tviNV&BYJrk;#KZP_LJRclvd;%1t3xz`&+Zg?umHvGD7iTfDe+67D41Wt; z(drwq`#)iQySoh#a>K!ozrFD?ySM8&4x&OJXrUhquYp%pWh+b>%F(>K)cAT!eo(A6 z*w1;^kwz3sMCdAZaN6!pZfy>{e2({LUTu*dkV!t48|)~&!6>vYRL~4_rs@S<0p6i*$ZHt z@36U-z3IW7`*)Ohb1~^{qju_DlGBUD&X&hY9(r$fu=5gGHpDd40xXEgxMa!(CTD$6W~h#1MOn{Rl1xDkf;(-(}< zGK;{T#NK zDL7SrP1RS~8uDHZFm?H+ZducR1g#+@*7R_>zPf3+s*ZSa$BPNp9aC%{C^Z2vzce3# zm6H;ypDr`z%O|IbZ5pB7aml{vlnD13aYA2Qm8OT()7U^kZ9(TOA$=}AxBg5+uN7b; zt}nCKW_gjLAxnt#k$K-JH*U}%o#?HRQ#(6tgvX}uF(yHccC*UZtXF-X)UOqF-GN$D z!}vM`@4cMU-FsekRb4YPDtNmIpXTOlw5B?ilDwM?+3lhe#p2;WO%HZB0_r?SSW8YW zd3U^%Jj*gc>q$b`$FljZcCUb(u}Sr2k#RW9fEJVKXJ?Jax#h#I*95;Q1EO2Ybw*Qp z$pn~Ki+wl7`h*hA&;2?PU<#^H7{*U_FC+4?u^Jv^XLRM}+;QDu<6>&R#PQ_V!9g%| z&=cAL@!0Y0A?-4(*w7%u?wg=9C+$$c*|6jJwR!aBo^r&zKd2gb?5F`>3qR(Exe;)6 zOKa6ek5r)%c8j2DLc}gJ2oijHYQ(Y0%BE2io+Bqe-rEoj%stxtCd-&@3y9PeLT|K! zUm*}1C@Ag^RjqI2goVtm^~vdlmtsYxb3co{YBPS4iF?AChiM~?Imx(^=_cpCe|TqD zC-n2lL}XcF){Vly20>#t6ln3`WVEQ2Pb znf&SsW3}SwG_^{&@gkd#R0^LZB{5?er3umT-~p`Gu90rSjk07oY?%yj53-?ToQxl+ zeB*P68;*Ls_UK5Sk83y7e_w(5@Cht$CtUa#IcDDj=Ss)#BBI3;eDVJ^eCm$5SQ7FU z9HTu}TS-7H875y@3na-?kQpCAUPLds&9bZqctX-Z;|-lV78b6+RN$#Sf|KW}FCcTd zsc4qDk+Dfbx~2eptS)wi$53*r`D+azSE+E-VADmZ{sf@)fraAs7=2D9fJmm`2O==K z;~fEccDLR>{l?0Izx!g;HqP#E^(pZd6q}ZohqN+Z!qnD~Ad#3H!frH8W;X_I(Yi_` zQAII)01;V~Ubph}a4{vKKLon23D}l%4eFq5Y=2X!v`I(shYQtHh4NfwOR$H@n4Kl}!Hdwf zo2`oJK3uY$17BLW^Wt*ibW~W=&*i|KHgZJHEBr#rIzty|XwRO}yZfYTW?Z9e#*L4M z6tm`x+i}MIy|mI#*(^AQ7yE65iq$R-(A=MBGoJX~lFnt2H~%M%d5%y^mR#VNZomBF z6189K9srFj1WpO-_NjLxzy_p|Mfq%ke2P}0HdN1KoG)NVlaoGi22UcEqM4|EACae} zp?12M;GD}QR&&N=IptZ%t+|((Ptm--2`)hv!+PSQ_VM6A76dZ~yDNZDKcwb2-pXq> z8C#jEtOOJiK@A|*1(m9oW$>|aksqJ98}~@uB{k` zh`EiKxCvxdZ2$r{Ke%KmJJg*Fg9-or%N^Z0VZh`JhTgqC(5d-(# z`7nbNY+yqXiAODAg@?pfZ}NMf-AD{fb{0>It@kvcS1JS$(u8GI=^~y|5I5gJ;C!7; zPZ2U%GrKSJ6~Rl0$tlWWeB*B8EiWwRhopu}3^GlaEJ?JyHz&ENN&Fm%0z$I;mv`)@8oTsT5qFm( z{kZslG8Yr`7tF=Z%=ov=m8~HiyZ%2W*FCL853Te*}|nXdTr4ynaAbrcJiJLYPs z_S$IeQe_;|ksHDdubdw4&HP4X5wgO*7QaJT+GJ8F={;3MHMyGK0X+g)6Q2X_A5#k@ zws!xpN>{HKTBnxXak82hM(y34YoLu0vZ4E?wH3Bw#%jpue9!)wKq$*aX^CnG9c^r{ zyT(!uj&1+^M>qVZpC{fN&ZXk5_Ryn6SH=g<6}-EuNRPp-24Mlqb8bvsz!|RV%tN|5P-xzp?jqgIVeQiV-vvPcHxPh1(xbPyhdi=Ya+HvV?NHh8be2R68RW7JWx zexBRe`Hi)lf=Y5=nKqD)aocMpX$Vin7Nj+4rOC=qsyn%t-s?r<>Ls3ASZ_DT7h5{ zQI#lM@tIIHVkDPxsIcP5hIZjsFaHcBWpTFF62&#uI5o+?^k>S42}a}^%xJiNmv8{D zo{h#q~D{e>Z7)(Gvf|)$(b(As(J`{$7lg&6RDp_!i$|~$E~Rcrj#+e$SrdOU{p)Qn}MUgDGgn^cy<#Lxqy09?CSugJ!m%iyfe>hd{W~9T$sd9 zL(_)UFg*nnMvds6lU#O(U(x$Fp(KL z$6!vhBnGu@@Aea>i6iLPImaES$(*sQ30U@|Q8n7JSjPh@9{k3d`Qj3EtF-&$qkwqN zOD>%^mbm!sm8(!*pQ{+5frdzfmc<#^0({pTRGZ(?R2EU}^-%ffj=X&SBpR7iI@*c4 zm&dsNU@*604$-jeiKrS{Bh3ToA+Er5#tN(rRqPYT?l~W zfioON=9y&Yaj@;R?^1&E&ybX*bjPUUC2alrsvA^f&7=HRd?DW zsJ8){8yAK^|JmV?H3@yhkpj%n5;dY?WT#yt>V z{;0g+Kx!6$TS5=G#wQO!9ax>ivPwS zh-vip^w3a24sA<$gl9`c(!5=#^My#YF5;yJCalP8PCE%j7Wp=uxf}fp5>0>@z@6PG zf#nqnwxn3dwF@@c4|2&YI=|z<9F`EkVK5fHCbNf9We{$*=+Et+8vf~^!b=8ZVIjj} z432(%z1iBf=+=|AKqrGNrw_?1+)HNqW`0P;=575KRxM2!jdzz$30CO_R@lZnlF;9? zLFP<{t5_$Cr8WbD#tuM=hDT?Fsx1#QfWw$Cm}7Mz5(N7LVqHYS$C=AG?tx+PxV;UD zh6SuZ-IWzgN}X^}^~|gv>(_WdwQSbU6EB}d`dg7e8mMArwJXF?s9f&da%P+KGU+2} z?a<#?R_gkjvgx{{>w80Tq2+z}!GyZf>yjbuJj3?qd0K&4d>LvT&SD2te4q~yAwo1; z1g^-xr78dc26FxW79Hv@2BW1|)Fa&S#QQ0;dLUGTAlG(AGyO)Y5Z>iqy)GtPO$H|Q z(%vOh*2GN`aS36jC*9$%cn)oO6Z{Qf8SKR{on^HCDy>s0)?Q`tEGnRLGsN9=xP|7; z$ablvyN3h`@6p>{u*^yFR!^WD(gE`$s0d`;|1N(Q<4B{`g%mJuSj0~nlQJ7FEXE!_ zg|16xj2yBoDGH77WSsTW}DvX^#0k+R-%`X_b}^&if5I;X(^ErrKodz_-<{Vr>t zOlt^=ln`=1wBPaL-Wrf5pP@`O&gM{}@bg`UH1&G=k&4K1K2R2dyl8xAazTfw>DJ06UMZRV{C2X)My-3jPHq+ zyu;DBQw8&fkjv>6C8D5+T7E01X!dnh8a|#NFyt<8t?Z@bPpz0?wD*by8iw+3wO)ld zI|tNrQynkN66=Q~1rIRtQiYW(k_aeF>j)K9j*0TLivIJ zTL^jI3SB|>YLodv1xDhPoz5XesDD+)-zB|bhYNzNuYu>HM(Sl76-J)~CZSl~MH3>%`9!@)GHeS0$iXEIgfhbXEoNaLN^cbX=W z;Qr%bf{}$JO9$av6`8X0vyEKkjo8RDSaCrAI1_0PJFS>DD>@hl?_<`g%i_u1hd`7% zftFRhL5MRAzUo_Zh7lEq11JE_zEI0J!XxtmQ4EZ9W3c6eX&r&_$d_~Ti=7NlbgMw~45AbJZdQUU;^?YN&_UFtDNA5V=3=CfCTQ7f zc!*_{XF%3C#!70XdzZIRE3d_y;z}dG4A0(yeY5jHVQjUo^CfjK?G@;?2+X@=UO40E zr0F6*9DxwV!r?VNv+4P>^_-$7>^H=WNvAvBm?fJXz*QY9!+uOxpX2eceZ(DP%snFbdQNKV;uh7l zXDLGV^wvzEqi)C4#%zN4fu*&*lu(G_WQg5F>s(1s2}=(3kh-8I-u&|@Eb!M zaDG)CE0q2)Edk|i379(V?U(3Qaz_;IYUNI1efq6@J#R6ki@*5>zt4A!{!jE}X80%i zva|i$Z6x^rpYK|$NZYP4z;yjqd!hhtvK+73Ux7WV1#EW$bWwMe$0bEX<0lxsxV;jO zXiP+D4WgHP8;LckH^VocU2cy$D4E>oPo&B3kTljwo;5*Nk7o|wma%e21#o@Ae3 zI;r_~Zyz5%Kg(ge%0XG)^t2T1B5;NMaV-0rqBGDeJ3O^=3~%=4IR|I@Hs_KT9btTr zKl2J+&K>u_y{(!m{G@?`GNN&eYV6&}!%SB37nymHW!20KskY9WO+I3H2=djW21 z2(IMO%@8IV23Zf-0c{F(0IZl_w8J(y8FvZf&1ln76rboy7_z5w4dfB=rnXw2%xkBM zj_qvaprwQiq3=u~Pd;-aNK_FH$9n?m0e_o^{rYM4&o*0OZM(6PrOdn|C16hS;SyBv zV#XWcdX=25A-c+3Xe*D6XmL28Q~hd6`uY0GGBRIzyp!@E{a=(@M4Q4rijxF_ClB0| z%IokyIPE-(mL; z^q}Jj_@-p#Zt18@BD;bqEMy@k1%o^qu0=u(Ir3{fCX*x)yK_Q{rUj`80K7N?UQnDN ztr3Fi>aNyh@Kyy>BFp+R*c%DQb5|^idllrvnR!AY6!LBqqV)p+jGSykLp#c&8~FXE z5wFCx%B`v#WM2U=5I0p`J4GDpd$x|adlNd|0GZl;1h*j+lOS{oMgdY@I@LmZLTh8d z*KO#RP!zR_agk537?Q!qLr>H(~l3=~5^t1w9D%91NZ=cH1CUj^i>PV%KX0_ z<#b0xd3r<4_s z_g~)TOd4I7Q%Y-km)enK;S%Ukz12={KQoXY4z8!+I~wK4RBLCWw#_jgCls=MAtuW| zixLydzwey^P?ha6kn0C47{P`9yNI2STqM85+ zoq(dWVdG*c3D%Ie%R9$8gr*pEZxqED$U7qF#XwfxGnu|hJ9xkGm+TJr2B)_kv<#zB^UiAkNhQ{{bl@$?i+D#QeeGDIs_O8|=msIZ4=v{g$sN9$!r0Fcfbp5f%A zLS9ihW31>3WxG;ur06Oi!MaorVf^4Ezvn~XBlP{pi|@nd2QeVR)<^6c{3Ezlb&i(5 z7J!*3mHrozv;A`caI*e8@V{69%#2G73@U#jS7u;RW?)leU{jP}+^5=S0)qq!h9&$z zu|o|NYrWtJ=+k-2=>{j{&neS+mjIZ85^RYQuFCfkq>Rst?(ie<5M*yVJnTd50|A_? ziFeA!*`wXc_g4+TlVMuU}+zIt+vuk&{E!vRP0I=?IhevX2z1gzCG~m+P(-s#g^(6nZQ?>Gt3vR zV*Qf5NuMeiow!G>1iZ#9ffCMQxwn7GkByONJ4O<(#%ztWky<;htqiYjK*)kHTo8sq zz@hd$V%J=oTKkF0huV%C2!pY@-JKsvB}&)F2049F357CXhG|#{fGQ3z3gNRirq+DsOPB`Bvq~L*qQ%Ec%4Bb%eP#ma9 zu~-wx8_cTbLlE~D^BO8BKut7eY|6OGculjvv=g8@B;k()W(k2v~_rr{~q^~yCI}y%6BETm3I&( zmy!7x!6EopBtfDmd-@u{ZB+WOrXLn#(|nXAl%;h!n5o4Q9Vo9_V-dEWjAO$WigNx_ zQN}+;>i>TJ|G|-&g<-CN;ZJn|(3h45g(eP05v~@ZlSbGA7yxBVaBR)uX}#}9rIBg5 z=k?3iddca6A{8wv(|VBwoPr9`dZB}w4S@oy)5@WP`V`Fd#})Y?OrGrd_yh(;Jgp$jI=Ya`P9d)Xgw6{;N)c z86YeDpHz^A3I3IfB*~Ejr@O;RD0Lc!!-*$=XzM+%H>y;Glv3+`Hc%F-U;dv|1Ze-0 z2_X9D|76im!Kp0qRyTTZI*K|13Xs6HSo=lbjQ~l{1 z_!CIVGJ087W{SBkFkBXHND^0O;dtGX1+OT!XJv;-F?W4yB$|}+84A$nDeqU7ZFOyr zG!J!MSzTApG7?{2**8Of=K~L&P5m{0w}E0Hd&>+#C)cOPv2lmYUs8YYW8O=xCJ zsFFt-TJ)^5Lt|TKe_Kb7y9NUDs9RfKg3RcZ z7J7j8BIDidP({j}cp3DRE$xK6C;1P2-I}bL%bKEnFIu@GlA;8ILTYNd@pS!aOG zaxA0^^i|{{;v$L>no_{^1b!sKlTe8_C)tv2M}6BHyl--Kw4{b4OZ?_zy~@PiB-Od| zcI9_iXOr6J*krg0(_ZU^CFz_e5qPF9f~I(%#oQ%}>|*?mL4|bNpSByIXQ?<&&91Aa z;Mk(Yz0T#lRtQmgG>3pbrI-vD$oOHlnm*h3Kendwzfku}i2i%-+lc3t?H52081ZspY6#FfWq zOVmC`B}qZhlruS18TCGG4>|>z(nLA>b*i6v%7VpJS$0NC5>v)o#Z7vG~~@J^wivD0ofh)jAoeNEtNND{DACsXrx~V`XxyJeUWa8tCQ_#KnS5f z)jL7s7rF%P2{%$|(hmkNo^-D7wh9gjy#HWqzBQ~1QJ7{qXXmc7IH+}!T)_n=z zyzC>1>fTmP=?3Nh$l6t)8?LU~Vxo*Ypi^QY^CT3kkn~Xr}+7v0I$${Fj8_*UFeg8@u8oodC}H zJ~k;Ygz153!{iX)J#LGL z4mfH`tb)H{SVw_?c`khkc4HPj+yI>S3o*aodL|Z@zlMh3xNa#BMubq)UqlQtc!YOA zZOwWj6+P|&-yt+L!jd&LDOTIu8@-cw`jXM~htpg4?&TTdysi&Y`QLU=b|mGXx$*;Z zb{PjH;CcBBm0RTvxqr*G;MBI~tr)rzVzuui=;&_Z)qU5=j$c9D7)$5IQ3cuN2#kv7 zH?mGMl^?bMZq@=&47P{mN;Db>qUwe83RX3+`N@qFXo}Dv3U>zwdt{XM$hc%n0kz`) zTYnGUOho9@@C~(r@Ll9PkZ&)lZCWK`x2R1KBt&an@jj{f>Bgl^IU9s5*PYg!=9(UC zf3dbirtU9E9{g)8en9uLs;nSI6v*hU85N#PT^g8W8B*@9{T z$_&B98J6hcB=2N{Hz|HX%wZCjmCAKICj%bpwePbX!|cIBC?lp*ZEkTKw*x6dXOBMA z_Yqbk+C-RGpeccttUY(&Ri%(zfoWVywQ5r6YDNv@w*V~+XV7;J0Ck8B@S30OH13K~ zhm4F@8`{_aVVgNzLXdsy{;P3zK@_ly+EJ@vTKC%<{Q*p#Zq|3LJ!G1V?dC7i|AOQh z|BGJhKTR!wzM&x~H1hvqCo%N@#cCKDc3-d>OzXWiNUu5G%K13>g&K@ZXt9|0A=nDD?l%?0-W~{}VdO-oU57e^AW73A!n~AL5^(vwlU; z9Dl#BFJ|lD0t8^dw#i_~wB0~nKsFH(*Ch~;F~2!EFvy-B=gz9QH+rJr?L-B_1bMh3 zqNC&W=cpa`1%KskP0W*i*uB#^0!}dIeLw%zARL1WZ zg989oW!uVo7n}!vz}KyHpX^~-1m~c(3$}&ceaiSkhp&MAKle!f!nbIO|D(g7^VSkW z!e$4t1AQi-jv;}7j4ADSUoUH6RNs3SRHGQVzmARefSdh(8=-loA>hdWlq;k38t4r7biZrt~NY-WR0U4$gl_-MQWny zuD>&&=MxY;Wz)(RvVBF>tbbq9CKI~P>DoQat0t|F&ru~ z1C!rz77tczg7}DAayiCYs~7|rR~}u-kFLAt>7(()isKL>spDI&JS*9gs2oGDei~HP zd>(i;xtbP=S!)XE*(ySt@p*>;S$*bYfum_t}0z0ak(E$Ps`~wrNt(pKv8C zkDk@~`@J9ygHg9zxMwjYQq_94-YgyQbXIazq+pw_1#ywqxwf`Nk~T6doaZ zx@XEgD&g=?piO#sxnIcn1x7QnasKrwyEx4a*T(<@Fyr(vN4!8z5S^fEP_7&y0!EUC zf$%Re^=x8?6g+~IVT?*GvX~ei0Ms87-!!sL(sK+WGN|`h+!XCV6CL?~>f3h+m=UT*fSND6b@NUUj86igjzIl}ng?Ei65YwyL1<0GV#`aZ8m$xF4d>E*3gc3{o2|h0 z2HTpHL(+w&H$w=A9)$7?J;V5~{sD9b zzo?c4vTjgHzL5g15ruuOIA&?ChRZgp>v}M_nstx?(ZSvtS7kv{|uz;#&yx+J!y8;8kEmAGDs2(o%NcM{>AP1>ljS zMgSe|Z_=97EUfkx0(59br%vm`E{V^Cg)PHG=HM4I0~7bgW=L>LN%y@LYslJRpSVV< zM@7alU} z0yB%!A8$l)hEVhRFRw>H0X^6(H%FaL z4jmLM1PctINA9CnmdPM)LV|=FX%wF9ptq1Wtr9%(Q;>u?ZU4_X`^g{j$stktA}D*y zE-y6(+<$~0kn}mM2Tt-CDDm+L+q0tg>3a=MG4kOH0J`-Fo(u541pph-wt$tY?&B zE`GnP6-$=|E0i~3QA44dF#?f<+`hp~lSX(W)4_X~X5qkfx)*o@=YuNlEjfZBcx zay{r{yCk5qf%y^JJK8JT|GD1o&#zdx7nVz{w*?~-(Yl&c^@2g+NFDG}T`Vt1bQ+}}?zW`xo z#=p0sg8x(O>a^5Xhs3Y70J1oG5oKtC33h-Wsh~talTZkbiI$XGQ*7g?pTMk6h;A7g z8vI3o6x8K1wB0{GZtvZ=dJ$!>OVbQAc1J<*hYo)wfy#+2Lu#@IWVo{}OdfMZ&JGUwwF5CI^no~Im4NANTN|7b`)R)1kM zVYVQ+TnLgGRJ9^BMy^A2$H$H&XtSk`gW;VBys8AzbZ?%rxE~#^w-puw+?391{n?((&2k1Ov&L`L*O`s*ft&^I&8<;!p`2}z z{d1t|!J=`#Y!&K3Qhr&pwDw%^hS13DGhW$BLg)lZ{hOmQMCj~t{y*NVvKyHR-coBv`NgoCcc%omQz>VTv;|{QFAuUnJ%|DLY|EIP zYUqnj>{!4aTY&;08jn^uf-dlHs92gvjS@w_ z#O5oDHDoGSH!ZzrG>w+dB^!(lSY|BrWc=^<8xTwh{RN_xoqks6q4~po9}${tr`s0f z*sB-)KztZ?ok%u7saS|m%TGXg8+{|cG;m_S1on1%{Yv~V`UvL#Vj>Y8-zgg;fG`|t zC0Gv|+tc9(G>B&^>W~wTLZ+#KLEY3iV>ZdV$_EuIASsA(6c~ws4Y|{N?)7eJf=+ja zB@N@Iuv6XV5nGe|c};k29R853p|km(_b^BtvK{%o>rvD*RQJc0Z5PM7uHiu>F`tS$ z-|J%-0Hx@5NkMpbOqeVHW&!w!xHxepQJ6iLnTf>H0s=?Z^vS-7=$Ig;sN~=X3UBvk z&>(HtR01hU8S!~jfP_}hqS~=Ze<4CE03>Ygq?u`YaJr!>-bR~wNGpfA=7)HNUYR3x zW8o+b6YKK5mif9K6YBSg?=7VxV4}>FBK!1V9|oGe*^G2?9O8j6fyt8Cl?^8<&Unr_ ziZwgYlU#_G>I-BYwi}HX+DkP=GHp{ETa6#Rp8zNCXSQFg{x7iSznQE!C;Z1aML0>} z5qbk55sWxd{U6`-&mJNh8xc@Byq~?L@Ck~+%m?{AatzBAak$T}di~rYUwcr|&YV;4 zwyBQR&h#GqVO6J=KhV1dZi`Kq6J6EX^1EG&1^&?O$>Yf2)y42J@TbSk9 zmH>(&n}`EGoc^vM3$dv49H9y<*r@PY7_l7xT8LV}b1r5)Zfb^JUsGtQ!ofwA-d{n` z3PDN4u_W7%CScuQuP2!NmI?rDXDLa<2O#>2T3>{<@%@M)V@2J)*R|oqZ$Dq5CyeU*+hOKCHLehj!&!nV83`ct zqasGsL$$xLLEQ(G0Cuqf>;Tk$6f48ma?I4nY?@apqL5iS%Dj*J1GUAt&S?x?bk%xwZ(WZdm6^~U}V02)Z06}{5k zm$Hy%4tiirYr7AheI1ed#S{2~>X_L7p6aaU{%6gDZAW7K%jpjL0YF}EcY^YtMPJ-E z0uaFI&cZK+*IN(@wa3j(CKHx)eD{k}qq}oMOUK%X*4eFD^VITrbsPLt8)KQJFno{u zl3Q6$@k)Lpn5z6z$H&{JJ8zYLeFSV#kdM9Ir}vTo(8~=+AZVHaFc?3#Nec)eh8h69 z1muZurbIUnw@*mOcn%-aAS-Vo_py&G$uSJZ6O3IrnehYqbk-z|c?I(&3eaGgmB(;j z*L_Pd-9f1;w8kG=$ngTQ++8hY07mDH{gwPFu@p`CX-2h_sIs{YbgmyE3 z7oQBU=_k;CtNu1@O=?j7g^YhOuu+h8#MG+VpiFk8o-FB; zm-9mh&xom;N5wFmW&xJYk@_we=(r8(THSSM^^JW4M56_&{hYeDy1S~M^*+YSb*Wb^ zcscD|(587QCv|`3_sC1hFUuQAJPq)x{jm2nZkQGQXt+`EB}8tM(FgYZ6!cDw$%B4PwUV4 z=TBKW)YHjLa|e`}lUfZ#C`FwRoJj<~DZ~RsR%X49Ha+8mP(!_%m0O*9fQPusRsF?i=11fRgBGFI7~oZY>m&R=Yx9;96! zGnSk~R^S4{cyThkn@vxFu{S{a)yJFq6|(Nd9EirVANA_u^`5*BP#ni%dwwVWTv0nr z(6eM^ggI$I$=+Djdn|5*bOu%+=aRruL8?R3y=^Y1O?`SdgGJNjqqjeJ_x*_`n4I!E z$phs+RO-yWmOJVD@{@(kSP@8MaBH`kK@bR9kD@5L(_lb`%Q`;s}wP@Yc=D1ag z_L*fu6PJOlEvRx@sLEOrnNS~ieR24ID_h~&sF#2DNl8a9Z_auUc6!FwmrVnk7gS@w z`zeeUrPQGJeI-|Dum*VqVOxb>C%Re;y@%^G?zyJn(puRBTg4-TjnJ=a5P>(rWcI4j z{XS_)q`i?1YfiR+?}F=ej%}9hg8#=4T{E$Z*6w&YSM*a+r|npX1p?iI7T6s_ofIlkBwe>S zR%sc~FnE6nX*h3hI9PNZ1~(B)sRS7v{siFHx7#+ZR~fYXs^YXejM4o2X3lplg-8|N&*>~<~#q`W|U;i0lX z9BD4@%uS`yP$1V}c-(qn!~>Ab5TifA1dWnzFeB|GM2&i_UC>^;S3@jq5!cd2@s7<=3y(5S@? zSxdb@9U&ErWO84NgJN-59k>3)>?6hh!`WLvRoyo0!*q9dcXxM}beD9Apn!CDw}41D zNP~2DcPmJjfHbJU{%;K3D@RspM_Rmmtg~8ArM() z4xXoT2aG0v2V}`45YE-C)hiz0FCq2Zyk46cb(25|d!VTts=bmnMXepr$M#ORg%RGZ zcFB}q;K2)xi;o``Z4r2{rJKiarn%t~xrZ&ns2jB4qQ80c?eG9Qg&XUpgd1zo1x4B? z=&|gr%H+tZCSKD68?r+=$B0#LAzSbh5IOe4K=1^$A>X4M->5Hgn#PH6S@y&mx8XZ^ zlEbr+2B*tXej4Y5BwPyTJE5<)@bCCYsMB1D3}KjINk8ngiI+)Fy*d>yquCEaMVbG( z9^_-EJA6_A=OFFGMycT@rH~ku?M}-z(kJNVOi=mBKKQQTxg*8$`_E2pwor!iuV6bv z=v=Hpm=#ox8YuemRQLZTPWX{19+JJ&GsD#(E`;lE*&nEG8bM0W5}(Kbod=|JF*6{_>HkL2a2XF0nOyX3EhRl=i=C) zCf>u%vX8!g_e6c;UvLlmncwtk7?h?UZ0mr%futHo8Ztw{O2Jn^!$q)37$_j0Asmga zK2mta*+@YFtCqtx=2;IFX7`oi@ML1kJEsV-h2#b>^$^n+&Xt8fLDIy=RdG7ArDXk? zt{_fsK>j)@mQ+Iixt`WJd1o)J0*KBOU`hL*4&e`OXv{dfLcbW$A;23jDQy^wjTwsZ zE{oMlh=rpoory6bdd$zN>q?V{>__5$Vp&|Gw0|dY`HbQk<@psVXD7dK4KlXHK~uqq zs?n@bM4Sx+3S!y&FXJcRt>9P4?+~u22TQ_`g+<#x=buzgluE76zLf9B3CjZ0_viI@ z9D3-&^$!9}GFpg|(XdLZQjmnZ4_VZIP?IUvedQt79M>Gi2@`em(Svz!B6=LL8$&QL z;tP|ey;k)HHIHI%b&;|-GSQ%nw)G4AQ?srYpCL(!WOP6rB@mE_gZJsNiRE=oCV39gKZdx^Lp_HTELLHH5|||zQV1C(PKy!M6Si;iK&bWj`YnyU=VpS&BUrg zFJ6~NC}I=S9|Ql0zH0li9bYV+KE7y(94+X1Zdon?sRNsC%&S@!jdARuqhg z&3O2j@aoEXOvbCiu4gSn_*9wCu(=)k{guPAj^nT&#VciRH>YoJp-*DLPs_U)@4$n? z-?V`+F9xz7U>xZW4VqSWI)E5z-1iZ+lc^Y=)}tV<0n^iO1JfJAH1>`bhZWP7ldl zi4N)Ru{`$N1*Q_Ocx1A#l33k$&<*Kt{Xby2-9mCDs?30}0w}n`{`5m;G!3k&0h!b5 zUq(!ZC4BB%g~Q_|AV5S!$e5XIK@kPB!f&KOLqrUYnC^nFnY$ts`^PFU^hYyICsnDk7M4%F zb<7FSNgHyT5*yip-KK3K=a(bBEZCoCu_;9=Sk>0@Tk0yqc+FN<5(%ZM)Dvn3{-FfJ z-2w4^By@Q`*loj<4fe-M*lXIwff(-!)zda5JNC(hB>`81Jc&(9$|e=-d7d3TNRg_`f4ZRHh0c)mnN1gR)<1c(wj5QqQsHROK! zHfT-!MLd0c4WWvfJOU^MS##t~BpdjI_*B?J*0pfV3R8OM5p=>+Cnji5#hDg)^-iH1 zl+cx}ojne|6JkH7x@v!r~EkRt0J>b!D{K)viK@NkL5Od1=TJ@JO+e~jZ z6-Id*=N{seky@aS?=bfe^e#EC%+VRfbo)RaAlY3BrQeJmIb!GWUXCEn^bv$Iy)Ysi*j8p2=NYL{KC}lpC_6R6w+XSI$7n} z!9zY&iib1fT^#a|ZH&fl+m}p0H zC1K?fe}~f%;dK@&FeRilT5r~A++nU&#pi1lq z>qA#0EKGl27$y4vZw44FNs+wZS5iEtGB_ACJy0I+(-;#C=>|o4dRg_3Fq_EYtjRN2 z=rLy7RAT{1Jv8L4(~Po~1C8ZVR^Sy2FA`Q#Rt#9D>iJ=9h;n>nQ7<8ziuGwhSP2BM zVCR2&;a6*17y*JE4SGEo3sEBtG5j5(4Uc`_F_d2yGgJjrp8_*9HZ?GHN z+(T;xaR}RBdk9<57LWxgF3#H1sWAlQbT2ZJoP)mDYVGk325HeZiUynR$m5wcloS8?wImB30B7mqRp;kHnBK<;f&V-f)pp%bqUfO5IzA zsmpsybjD|CDpffmj=SV-84`!hE*gpyyh7r9!+Sq5s*Uq@$(lK133kBjgY2r$$(KGB zZMXC&qeFp3d&+rraAycrKS+5&D3};<^=wZ(B%x3wxfPSp=@3eVILYlLXXu`5>{7uM zIWkKdf3@`$s0F!R)Ls;48hNO_&LGRSatrI}6@WR)8qe2_1IRVj`iw-(*^}JRZ`aPg zlsJ;(D^AaclkOk}gCvJQSPTS+VCQ>!PO)&j1|d)tSShAN?!iBYrkF&WyJ9GjBuf)V z5r2j}tr-&_U2(AR;yay4pm~tZ-r=iHgubtCCr)oZH}54$l8;lJ?XU9v(?=O>5sRkrIH+y(9y@Py+SU$bT7y*|4yw zmvwAdc?5(pK!yHXPk+OW#{YhJmd#8NE+8a!p}B?=#28Q~Fn>Kfo;%(22=pj*gV-Gl zt{yQyL5lA-!zXsh0yVrLIRR|_N5E#G5$fj_hT9o?cj?oFJ0VCKDLf9w3-u**9?9U; zjrsG$er5kLYXv*`o zLpz3Bx7FVEb+z06ys2Z&{BdKymW4hU$(;Y`N0?R3OR>)Ia~lwSp?shq0ngLBxQwQ1 zfHg^AEP}}a#lgj@dIW@|QO6(M7!0dSV8v-+U#rXJMg|7eUyVbcbja{5I=G@$`572o zS$$s*&H&IxS$s3erkrr+-IX4Y?^&$rm_5Mg4Nr1uYi^nUAQ85g!ScpEx&|c*)3?d5 zZF=MIGTxlH@;k-uzB=xUBI}-nm?bn1i*oN5bj4ltwy?qnRxkE@Bcm_0s+^WdJLOtv zZ{Za=ZF65)nn*hma^+E)uEr&+Bp%toy=DGEW?!GK#as$Q-X2^i_k$J#IYKWJqTp@sm5+J+KEVjtZ(>62DT=CZyIoVO!l?Jj~-_9Z9ly5W~hD z3BRCO)mUy9eoH@1IsC$w%!dJxFib!0B9rWxw_A@01JH!u#jl<_F;} zIryHQEouK+zlFXTH5vp&}(EM{Wkq3_e#onY+jbv@8rWH|pf8 zLZ?5RFJwF)+($z%19d_#tnF}!maVP7=*C~;l+_J2;C#d~=q6)C!5KDAflubLXqRO+ zs&I+%=YmV@rhMxQE$0U_M014-6hwt;aqL5J-P*=0B|^{f@1}gezOI%n(F(xa0&GQh z3V7tdIvD2aNt-)E3mDEY4?A(AW64L;3r8=dcuo~Fmf#x??jVI?;D|zmpwP|M1oL&B zRLMoTN7)_0e1nB4*41TkDzO7>^kE_rgsDM!Vcw^|0*|H!7RN)Wv8ZNG;l>c@TJzkA zhdpT2(`+nF%jae!@+$`O&*&a|2)17VvX7W$xfbQmuvl%z)TZ1SN2#B`FqAX?vOoB9FKT=Alj6t3s>|*&k7Uon_mnq2 zkk7@SEn*~BATlKb)A6{~Q0>(?!M+aUOS}m^M4G1$NGZ4ppT^B+B?#z1uNZ9k1ddq- zHZ~IOi+bQnikGQ0rG&0B^$=^bk79lS;JelF>!1@7c-LDMVetN?Q-k$M7Jaa4np!wh zU--c^TsHqKD#sMEzQl7I6k-Gghyhw zXc(p}Q8k+7^&2dN~DUf#+>Rh(~9-yE+-Am6;A6a;Nx-JC8jqSWm_r4sF~EKFe24h zV=szB1zk)aru1jBI-;hOLC_xgLAmNbp!FQj)z}58K6)CWzgACMqCmDzRX{&S9=k^a(MTJnVDBRp$@@|`BHKe+qEdm zn)O>tCAU|tQ{ggYBlm~K>#OhgMa!OUj{Cf>bWDB=p5}ocPsOQ-AwXvp6*@M=VY-O=Yk6?~R%+EVBD|_az!d};VQ!IfJM2-B2@agpQ6zrTgUAqV8-wE=D3CbIY%3D=KPby$=qKl1OE*v5+;u`^i9n8CJb!M1cihle<(~yvpitS)RIC{{thtc8${BI z$?Th)q)(t=vb-hIdgj}yJ#y7QuYk2VW2{~o%!E*rbQCmf_Odb3w|CXs$NGKbj*6@K z__<)? z6bF#(9`u$QULk>c@7#1m4W<@~`0hQI$f)LUNxqJt@@RADcX@Gy+FLfL0`e%_`3Hd5 zP4@L+s3acA3UR+*zXRj-kT1BXktT?yOd#g_M_|Ck_VhH^eDbg7Hq0IPi=&NWF&rQ(@eb-Be~d;LaHuUptwP+AYj|Ww`2C*+Sj_6i8|)hcfKR@ zA66U>++@DIe|>r;O|0;C?ciR!Q0MM>;SMl&{nK6hU}INek3snGr=c}!nULMOVtQ6430NN|~*Y@Rgxnfx> z96H$NbDl`yM8ms%MG2WB-^rT~m=VqRTXJ7hwN7xL38tnX&PE%uFH&lJwi{rYBq6UVl%c(r8x#NAX$nEryi)eEm>mM_?*13)6*=$K+7WM2-ARRtUmrZt%w^e(ko zc??IWY{`4Sc5;{5Vp$Wj-T39Mz054`%jM{+;`x4D9rI(y*98tD=ZqEdll0{{3AeAn+6Qr6oVF1xRuqhCW&e}zE$&%PPHi9&6x!4rS`qPA_ZFt}|LERIOLP7|`_dkQx)E z3scgbuh#{-sp>hTaBAYe6lw1%3%*<{-;Ou_ge*5ocn3_31-QKNia?m*7NHv>$u-P( zUDUqBmDf>XPTDQ=l5t)BOu(A3|4l5>*ahPfS$!jxoY|1SppRG~(ukYtK%_<|;Uvw9 z^lj>G)S=%3E8}}VmvZY>CDBjA6BnhY5!m((_9uy!6uCCY2g{bjd-kfMnkq-j46S04 zV{+1I+8Qot3w-64nzY;zSTRXLnP11{t_mX6U{OEpPI+E%nA_gGV5j_f5z$1Dy{+on z#1W6<^l7lnnY#aqOt7|Z6sx7wRl(lOEzxr*_f?$(r2Op5CWZ|ZU$D}cE3AL+3p*Q# zOeNPJ&_I0>g_VOQUqCsp}0sbz8%& zjH(GB?H%(I;eDZ179*fnIvZ0qqAsktsaM`;&-~qM2e2v{VMG~8_;D?Avu8zm+OX`A z-K}<1IiX1%+1^s2=|P*`PCVJ zWPel-3bmFL=RlSjSr-&*8>`sA=U?kj=g8>sufu-fa;^*M-S3}2v?b_j3s5k`%nHSMy_ z_i`jXQiAaNTHa&a3vVmIEPqk7hR@_rPK=3|K8W)lWX{^ceRu<>0%{XLfyzI?@5f0% z9*r1MD6wV9Hgz0YC)h}4@QSkTziV9hV%3RkXLv#g9?4$8(fD~pHD0#*YU0ayO$T+~ z?!F9nI*L$BhPjy7It&v?HsX-JqS2cjbp7b&92Z4Yr9C;S_;TBz&<*x8y-#v{ zIF{mul!ER=U*1p$cz8jYmN<|FybbrkcN)c!z9nGkTONmMi}-xwHUzbo#(kJgCofB^+-r2O&tD~FKUeZNJ zSL$lGCvHLeLWn{tl!3A}2x!Ui2hg%Tfn6C$^_BM9rkLRpk=TWZFOXZRU}BDvLZB+4 zL;FkSgIYvCHW66Ur-*!4qk|479`WAV$LnF~;?wv+D5Jw|!EVDw!_Hv3amjL|?rX0U zWs)r0MKzDn@stt8gwmtR+vBVIh>_JR{zc7`@0GiUSuMhlbPz6<}rjk}lDOJlWI=lQ4@5q1?Wz25q#~ zx$yiD#?S3FAo9%koa2VFNU~=a64On;0W;LErx->-N5oOZcLYlKomFHfQ0+&&M(4kL18zZVO3+JEgkj^2zb z$(fp+bneCjUD+orjItFhbrGpfvev1N`E^)5-(@#!9qge?jC=BswL{*Z(Nd%Ll|@t3 z`DGp3t`oJRjiW-82T6b~k^=o6q;t~O&oW8!Z=uSxpi@6IO_wN@#O&m+cLdAcLgkH_ zgUI$hszdz)6mk542t!O_r(GW#(tsrgUi~)uCaw*pr2IhF6~efxO)*O0qnz02>XDE> zN&h3^j!!EwjuCgC6!QWxn_AD?Y0>b<1oz2^k^5r9dAsLb*FxP=Q^P1N>$fKSYG0R% z!5=A>?=I5GZ(Njf>S^xfj5<}v{Q(?z z!)nV_x|y6>n~)m!U`h77+dd=7XTYNEo#j??+}45|(rH?XG)3?3L(|6oYQdRydlAPCLJ2=@Iy1jdlWP66QI z$p8TC*mnS_90z163=GTz0QCsfzo5(R5WxNb0Mk4R!n<&JBE3r>y{s533S$ofcHQOgc$abOLVWobc)gi+L zD{6%x1!WIVFzpWrQFUyOeYntOh~_|RK>o6ZvvZFBf187M4}>{@%4Mx|QiKe6eNG-N zbZpf?g*C7s06^Z7olN)YRmwdbVvH65a>VQbKsvGs?7#&NwgmnP3-=-G3_!~E;S9DH z;Af(J0cp||sCNwO50y6m1&p0!$jl@@ta>*<7gnrX_|*amAEJ%0Xz&$ypQrzbr+?}j zFxC&I$=qyACM0(Nur!wk09i`^Z#}dW5?dQkCISV*xSn31~*&C82|U^(jBVA|WANi~395lac`~0Qm^UR0F>Q05A|x z670IHeOT2VCP}ssO99slfI)FK{|HYsQ&ELG*g(i7xZhZ9ma{z;)Dl5}HI6@M$Uc5- zA5cYuSx;s`s5?LxpxyUEMVQvgshDE=yD!gdk+mPv9V%{ys8DuDo!nxq&EtX!tNR2Q zsza#S1hhS}zI}C5wD70C}0-q8@Zc;9l)6d1z+f*p*l3J)De<;{(vg%HC zYuv>OL=38N+Qo7eHl_M*948E5@xF^GP^R))@XMxt!&FMBaHy-!n><%j;6O(oTXyL{ zI^J61L3#BY8kgFzmlx4hwGf24f%oel4?X)I(4T&vC{xIP-#K%Q9I)X3e1Uj&o_6JK z0i>|qU^Iu~!S{6ReQ+j74}ShJe=C!+I4`Y(`hF1L;!lJxk7qj{%X%=U35*c4+sJJ` z5YB{rS7LmRtf8E@A-bi7Ie8|Q*VCKtp_rJSHA@fO`p6R?ZipRK>Mngbx-*SB`@XSe zwqfNEyLAECDC*W|Ogg_ul7K&6{NBq5JKcz4@P%t+wN?K+FJI5*S^GD>M`%W^jB|!B zYFrc3hd3hT0;9s;4ae$W!NSdfMSw_Iz4bFHfq^(&y$=h@eWI_vtARXZ7d> zYpE}g2fUy;j7YLNs zNJf!Jc?j4=t(0E*N`_?zE%=uLlK`+v>Tq0qrE!8O;EHBm84}w+-cLTL$U?5T8Safh zy-6=kP7K+Ww~+Xg=ObwtXAyrHvu%tWy_V+p$dkrFc&(N!4S$AwBe4gPi|8(M|2%Lo zD;S-;q(OTD>ajP)JsUcV#o)e;F_i&5u~brhdQ)z z8O^nBID*Pxv>vVqhu>Bw%x>%&Y)}j$`+`jjQw4)E3#h1`=jp`ezbl}`Z%SMgNxE+! z`Xfp*91;{5e+i{&;^CL9@cYz@D3Iiuhte$yeyW9J${dRK7Wvu8as$wM)7S@*+C*2= zBKzVjKiILFkp;(wv9s=H;2X$Y>|=y6%G7Qy7561l(eCnW(rT!>?naC#HyfUkSSv z4kn~y>5Vs+Jp!adzhie;oT6YFKYQ(o-jMahL_5&COCIHXpfZTb@$6#jEB5x0LoEIf zw1`!jhv z8_Gj1!@`Rrd1Z+5_;lTEwOe(heGo*Qwv4YL5@W~6Vg&6TqC>5+FXwVT%$8kg-ROE% z{g|ShJvMOJ->K=$-D57!(98x1ajbJq=R-)8rI0}qVeFi5bsqJ^h=5{pKT1yGB1X-iu z#%-(L(p;hiNk}sU?Yh4~XpOs@dPli16NP4pZatugfC0Yfm^hdsJH88O69skbKt$ji zf4~7WivJDNlPMD48-me0gUhM+amgj5NK-tj+K1ca7J!L|B@;2r4x<~ku;CAE+4Lu3 zsa%hd0z@0yZJ4;{racrhsb3rva(^p&LHBUYp@rgT#hdmcp=DsM(dp&kMy!Zvhw-!a z*3P1ZIWJGUQV*WqEPwWOB)YUc#vC(OaFg9^|LDC8$VjdC3aFP5u*u-_6zM=F~H1~xmj9E^Y_@k!6dqgDo<3I+cmt_I5H(Aq%bQTq5)q#B zV*Zu!u_nrk9gYK(!j`LMn%7gwQBBGGyH;$dySUq*Rt7;C9z>|m{x1Ra|67rGb^15; z9GM=cXc(OXcWQiqPCg%vvgx;bnGs1ZxhaFBY!yZmvAzp%h((n^I+~u<@JVo!jJ`)rM$${I5 z8b?pktLI1aV=wITHD*6LeXzc&Xr7*yQJK~J5px3oOatE0OtR<+?Q91y$)}dnZAM!B zI7+5*F;;yMHy2lw6~$a@1`NIf7;`X&tU%cWRBX@xbb`|Hzv%cl0k%%TnTSI)a=tBM z(IyDujEIjK>(XC=S<+;nHf(bMy@uR?ULyumeO>j>HLue|px?E{Q{~8`D|qP-8*NVS z6G_o(f1QS1l8QB0QmmfOV&x)`YE07-Gc2+w~5SqG|Un9{;nEGehi#u;%B zz6hru1V(eFGmAhc)ggrMOp{jeZ!yb4%9dwS!c@FVm!l8e$K-Zh<7v+|V-BNu zuPwuMugIQLm-=$ksp_d6Xxi2mXr~|Lxz#er8%3{_QN7_T(-_x%S>-@G8KJ>#ypu>h zPaSn<4Bc!o{i)=}I7MVcJiA@u`xYs}wx#b|l~pNDJKFP-cSEZ8sgZUJ2Fg3e_!G`e zp^nO7eIQDv>>MC)0Vn&@Ph$+QGy}|G%FrsH568rzW&2aXB^>`dg{deH9w?AN*QD*x zh3y0hY$fFICIL)UQX4oPMQ2-O7&$MbuVk2?*g1Qc#>RMRRD4RBA{Oc_^C>Qaooy&< z>8>nmF}OH;_?}mGzxviz^9@^EOlh{J8(TCxM#_O^9!3%u#gtNV)wYBzVu?vPG{p!$ zZ9i501}2s2Ky*F0RBXBGB;?h$ZNal4iCP5lRA!0zZRecAQ_a&dTJrr7HM*^F#*B$X z(lLV^k%S#?)nUav{&;20f>|NU?E{=rdW8pDxnlFNb^5i`eO`r2mE`0vYG$1jS9)_V z7?f*wIv9%xux|8`iv40C5XAK;RtCKS{{_Ez=t%pn1M2Tm2kt28`OJ^sx(;th>)Y z%|8Jg%3$8Yd>eQRgd{HD@HwS~CrI~jq{%3DE|bjl02$wy1jnwVNWTW1_5pQ8RDILTqkc4nkzw{%r2<8t)Pv!6x)g$gQZWi1 z0CqBze{B$%79?H)M6DTpVqUvufaMX2ed$F0!ewlxw(=_K)n)9|LhM^z>ZZb(S{d#2 zIX-gYbxr+wF&FM3+Sd6{btB~g{KN%^98B6u?nkp+)NbRmqjTWE z;!}5C#qBetf6bsb5|rw;a*0K9-%|MMy(|5t+XJxKKBi~)VPz4k;i2?;p7YA!n{Ji+ znlOSD9}LbNqT5hxS0d^wubgetrj3FvbQTCB&qhH6lfj_$+B^%|Dkeq+*GdcN;fc3Q zP7Bct@6)9xCgzx&T#Kw;k338&y7GskMU`76rDv8dJ5}4`({jI`JDR?1bg{#I3H-6* zFjKT9{XS(}V!}FEB`U>o)UAA3+HRRWE7if%Ge;EW^D2l=w#T^)|IA`=J)OhD$-Bt; zIN*Q_0>jD*A%*6bNLA5*7_g3nm?Hn*xm1MzkxTs_$wRPiShVggxZEZ3WTD_%SdC~v zH#BKf_zd{mu%mC`pfPhDwe;_OU z_HX5qIu5DF%b)FEpgunnB3CG9AqH%Le`MdnS^b>8qx1Nya_82;sGcA&Rq}mi>E^km zS8Ka&7?0tMTODHS8+W5+)K*)_=a)&a#%sqNjpOD^^$pF1jSUCidKUL?-oL!QSv0kL zFX^rya=m;V2Bx|Jc6acKp27^qH-;}UHp9cc9DO(~M@hHI%-;^;l&dDMnOj*E^$3Z@ zxer1F9FO4=135FTaw(iXwx385)rlUZa518k>qk|>*I@_rd!`n7u4Z?`KxeCXfEU++ zIx)1G_SBsKE@MXI8$DHRv&;dHm@|S|dHz1VOfKK4rScm2EsLfFj^f$-lGi~47BLAN z`Lm3NX6`pMZ?IO$JlEtsPZIIO4W&4vyusXWzJp;k6Rr}u<TMd?YF4o294&1F zX?>gsEICy*GKL%=p2++QP5@n|(Ae|Za*2@lDg={4o%oXuZq3N=RYRjbR5SMY5*j1k zY$zZ&^mHV@Pjz!EF?zrosTg%+KRW-x@<#*Vk;g%p#vkRFUds1P$CrQQ=5u}njzRN4^8QmDT>RNu3fI3QXg zz}YHwh0HxoHci?-2^?*~#>UB!7{UR+V1XilPZB*`f-7V^`k{m)Kh!IrZC7i&7h}=8 z%2j>-nP!(w|7P8cRHu*-A^wDo)_UJTbZJK$P5Bc1G2Nw_?l22j+&OMQc?CY8z=-cG zK0fBvb_%COaz|OhPhxLIpP#XN)0RPZv_BGuKP$2)y>7j4Cd{f8v9IbOnmFr`nc zb0^*RVDYb5KxmM$0~?$E@n~>xKmE}d|NBiaAKD#_L} z7;NtXWw0La6-6ZE4JR5E9{=!++x7X^2|ZW#z2LzlqjS3n75Zb_nrI)6hOOQ$#0tgp zn>O9V&e+E7Q9=y3m|*AYcLx1C(JGd=ODt)aDM$eG8x?ZK)icQobYMrB@+}V6R-*O)#s-dD!10Rkv|ys%L)WNVb20^ z4naIopyn)c{0Ye;{x9`V=}uiJm~O=I322u(LMntjH0jz4!MrBU1C{ceX7o7Y6D5B2+QI zj^4)E)&=Z|+?CVWhug1aO(raM35JX|=oRJ#iP`3ag&!9dsrMON$cs_}DoVsJ(iSeE ztqPujdc%QIFaJDkf54wB{Fi~?fbE9Cd_c%s8B7Nih4)wU39!3W0xJXyhhIN-6J1?j zH|>aK+Sq*_Y3%N1@WG~R$ucf%#GKpo%T|5?VyWF>t;_q>4JA`0vr(Xhv=K4RA{`fh zMo2Yf)ls3JDc80Z^KBBjL%_3v+vlL_im^)aR_!OZN+dy`l7U(ILn3i$YtN3pXqgPn z%QJWP5g+}Dnoil7I?j607&8s?B0qgQ76-mwQ(rKpcA#ah(FMDql6o5Zt@JcS5wZ`M znT7$VzzC@6@(=s4b3UDq&&jdKS*^;Z3jE2g%EqC}R;T$(h?ffr0YaMTKW3tZ0>>-; zb0%6&Nt6VastQwTaa16Yq)#s(6aedg3J$j*8n0;L-wlfdD;9qSW)A5L$q6Y4NeD>_ z6ybxG1XoQQoljznM+ECNrPT&?FF-{moPSWU``5Cjxa)z_-heTR>fh^%B%s67lPLU` zz%UZ>qrmVcNP*#^zY2H!p+739=-__b1c-l%(3j-08{40a=1pUmv_Y2Ha^065Ct6WQl92klgv2DmgtHN^s ziY#043#5|gf7Y%4JJuRvpW~h5y%PlsAZs9k{QbSKF+`)Fz88dRX6N~XjQ|e8;(Z*s zr!~dRp#@ZW20K?rYDQ>|X78B#km{ObbA zQ#+z0>T?6dACDLWB-&{gJU$vZI4zS{FnBl}7&`o`P4I9&FiN~`Dad#e7)&I#Kw_!t zZg>&H6!N3o5KBJckVTGQ;alb{N)D)LrrsU;L)}nbDEy{hqrd1J+1`U%HV7y8N3*|v zpTEDh3Df-7Hc3K4qd_@|WBffL5xD%vE2Z{7#tcfb`20uF`0?xkPaiB9T3?De8L|my z!0(%L9YTi=>dQgp2zj6Gp0!5XfvvT817~|=bZxG>?CiqDN(Q>} ztR@RR=&cV4h$Jw3b2l3ANJ;R=afn_GUHBJnTlS>JpHTIRzz|V)?s(^O(E_?SsQhNF z&oBPfpyM-syX2>wY<(oYub}s=IHTx8=A@Y5amkGKSM1Fgh+R@-LT(yLwO(ul4M}ny z|1JmxOgek9RT}he3y$XR9uG&2oI4!`w#Q1U5ZJ7e4wf zV>DsIrpLFjW|Cvuc5Kj}g(}E6^lXnmgMNJYQ#I0%flGRu_oL^RGHywKZOysnIv#r- zooj-RP)UdWPRtZ?1tJ+y64^8vUFtwG$3H?CMwIKw?Z+Ud_B=ze!^c@~51TsL={))5 z65^aZ59Jr0;Gy>1%ODmHYP{aRhSWXfCH(cWfJsntLSrgIQ~u43M+_(XkDclZ1nyLK zxZ;;to!o*FuD6O`=)3f~;}!pFlqbgD)$$iK#0{W66+{ri{s$e}oPR%pT&iq5T5JuP zY`nj{Y%N$M1oU{0`oEq88Jx!_;r0LeB#;1Iju*@WbvZXoRT=j4vC^ zL2t-0-cq-2Y(P6WZVK@4%;O17(tf`fKA6JppjHPWg!q$Ao@a@VT83C5D*F^{$rBAx zX1mb!rK+Do3RD@>LUI^!DX`{%Y=HH=IiYvaDpNW`lordi}TqoZq0TJ@z_c}x{&WX;^Ynfn4@r9H zS&cJ%Fc}Gv)E2K4IW=O;fE-WlLCEyXsg^wSnxQdR8bNR&2+$N!B($hSsQxGcIVOZa zCEAr$edelRihOr+gO7DrKJ4P?J_Hexz9ncf?BM@0xFCcka0Gn@#~aE(dPrX^7((qu zObH9?4>kHgg;MJ(b%eJHwnogV3NONtr}B%C-01uJtPs*o#p5+~px8f}%S@dgDH|jR z)WRiH3Shf+@xXi0Jd?oY*3?j@N$r-8(Fw#GInXv4k?7OQ=9Za~)L1_-6?;}QQ>f`* z4^1kr4fFVaZi0P=d(5=%4h$^%#uwjSzfgIYE6G}UZK)tS04O9AB!TW{a zw^wQzuA8z&11;ZYuBvdyFDCrqNt&_Tpr?0--anV$wS zG#<4ip9^3)3{$$Rn5g$3T8J?&iBAoSKhEKqp1+>{LFW@3O&obfyw>^`E1{s4I}^isk>zF4ut*g z(~yLA{vD2D{?D;lX}V7sn}vr501nME0gl9K4G75X=1 z{mBB<#cH#_6&4_yk;uCJ>L~z0U}En_@h01Y+7bp%b|Be5VCm4R4jM;d8= zT+VdR*^b4Gs>Fa;D#HEug91l1n}lc9&dMG|l+RyfoqNeVPY%;3XxLakPD;UEM&5I- zeNmBEk>%bg=pAn)BI+d5u>Er2fKiJYGM+&C17q~9+>e|*5rS-}D|fm>d1NJlJ`^>` zK9VBY0`%Fu{hsK8fUohlXdxH*8Q0eePSZJd14nEFTf4Hk_aT=?P7aN4I#LZS?y8PD zPYUJyA|B*syX76FI;2+&^0cH`T_E6uzGZ^CJ0QZ!KP#mCcW=N?@PvhaaWL({+17Na(|?0yVF|q?S`aFGDHI)u*pNlN6MzCR~aVLpsJ?Jd4Xh za476Ue)eS!dQWaqp6?g@L|&O9|J)Ng4l@JeN6rHfZwiSsZ;Xd@g^_|BfRyRsWfof5 z@&5_Fur=y_$0c#yj&8~-v;e8i_uL#84O0+|Jcyg{+&54@a4qN!6y-1hE{D1l+f0+x zEEXR6n07S-B{RHC?Q2E|GB$S{!?dX(XN4Wb($dT_EXT;ZVCq!$#P*HN&=K#(IOtEm}n`-gqr%MB54^UOkdZb za8t8_SSYJB$|LwPXyTJWuZ67{jORzUaH>+3hA?l8OJ7_e?rmj%0kw}HB4iHsr{lS| zZok^H=(QUG^T#o>;UHBG4rShiZz!9YFrz#J098oJ9ApL!t$5^`Bo@`LD- zkVshEU2|(!D_VS^m0;##4EZsYltuQJrB%)InyepK2`nwFKC29S%e__N*;u{tm9)D2 zKEVEtebT%EabzGm2VB*Kx~)Ygf3FP&RV+%i3=g7;1$TrR?QMnX8`;mu2tLSfAZQWX zWN0>qNl#G&?J*h1ryAr0Dd5}aCPyYi45z_0aa~4!hP4L$jH?n1{GsI1wEIo#{ef^k z{XN9Ta#awz^Xyz8Vsj4Qgqx?<&)-b_79Pe7#EbP`us9bMXU2TBk0qyG5+)(|hAu?x zJ$rl#Of7%huIw45#ihwnmId-#0%9C*TKJ3Xlqf+Tm2{l8l)IhFcU!nP&^Ha-u%xht zscG%%Y9`l1t!ZynE-!pm%o}{y&~6MoN98-so2l2!Oqr&o$g9+-USgF+nXSp@hM^5^ zaG2?Y*Z|SAF*Mqhof0dHEg1a4yf}24za4QRm`1!26epSw6oJX0Tl3f&-k_@A()ZgzMMC5LQ3Q9Cp1>O-|nB;ygy)_z{x0lgLW;?SI;q+DEVm} zd-9C*R&^8c0pfNyL9%g)Yo#u)k@Nzt=umv=G+{4_ZM}({M>FcjGMB5rd|Gn%ltinXkf>i z1#o(Q+fGyI@a0O4+hHPdxAM!yH}2!!ykO)uuzR@HRZwOF0X{hX1#16q(ocKhUsToAUvuKsR5Yiqo@bQa^Co|J!Pe@~RJ{mjKVc4N;MEW4N7n??4NKeKo58a$P9`xC)(S_NAJ z0s5Gs6=YlEDq^%(;A=-Q9q!d>R^6sVc~E8tfr>bQ^p2;V*7g};;LJumnDs;ysxLk0 zcgiN@o)f;iFBfP z^XL7+=*Z9Ttz28hk0MiKFxf+00l@q#iI zNPO{hV{vjW{OWQCH{&F${hg`hhCc5$jF)m^Nll_n^=%3)rBCgERZafip*)_qSm9rR zWC@^4^-EV*7XVU;U6M`)t{<$Bfh-vsfjTH=vs>~^oQ?;rKS+ihEzd%gju1`@vIr00 zUjhKssH*a(DWr*L_PWaz;_WLCgC#@*Nd4(d%I~{!e&-CmIfJ)B837c$V1Ih%jgx2o zS1=7@N(s&RJDu_WYXt4XW3NppzJGY`12|;ReLzBhxG%H^AwAOX1#}15R)bmqC^YZ~ zl|4?*sX8uoAQ}L+RyqG`1sd^bKsG?4+`riXo4~$?NZ`2H|2=yK3keCy(0>a6hlHCW z^;bpC#|r1@lEfA(f$EuqWWw44w}`}-sL5BoLmMHHm=B^K02Us?#UK27{n*6ve=qb( z-9I1HLO}rl?x)wAeSkw{AlZRI5Imw09#D*j&LykM!uI3;Bke8Ys@&FoVY<7UNq0^V zknZm8PNlm$qy zCv=cPa+Hd0VX+#Hpl27p{*mMjg6~q#6tB9EO{*dl;xcul#h_yq8=N?&+t4)H&gUuL z=xpAP2E+`T0OJ*E@p}cTn42t5RcrLK`}5OapA#>6hFylX0t+LKcS)|WM^T3B1`Ki+ zg&vC#%yW6QH+5TYY@BjF;cb$&apwsqSou+vEQ?p_sBTQB5$||?`61OJEq8S-SY_tW z>*a2zdUrR)G#|uxrzZ+CK!l$ebYsbrWAW_;!v_TsRY7DKZcF*jRm7-ADUJHVrlti( zXMN}H_vI_^L+P(yAphj_>kc$r9bE?(QZW4iCrDEDx6@@(n?tAw%0L_^z!=rA?(vrFY!?#L$ zdHR?gU>Ed<>F)&U4Qk^9JPycpj&(|tLg!X>eZb6kVPl&{HuRL7Z!2byf9SEETJ_CVvAWVVc|8qxy|0yVv;r!nPMWDOL;ovaNA0fhSK*$}76KKgj z;vfZf*lvK_17zA-q{==yUm}ibxLV$WdfwN}uL$KXI8|sIUFRmsm%G6Ueb<2grBaihv4E z!ECNGt|O^e>D`2!2XNRkT&KsVLCXjG36 zu}+(l9E|WgKHsl$PiXT}0WFXZ$ShR|>f&iLVNHa&G!iJcBvQyHc%K-uBfF$Gd)~US z*&-f0T?)Wxs0oo(=9DG||HKB~X$sT!BO~27P%lfZx>VBcY+~5 zpiKCkaVD$P5U^MibMizqL_o+@RyjZH4 zX2zAY=h(`!z47Kb=Y<0aG(DpmceI*KTMOQ;VQ?^;#~Eeu5AbWtF!S(~e8aGHrlWdo zk-~m(%EuE6R5|f(&-s4-l~G;$^4DF%MbXCI7M}EuUgMW_{f=}me&WgSyN!Jf!Z4ns-0l-J zcxm&2*wyg?Qae6+0?hFRffxTVgyI1G48NN&fjkpHj;F^K&J6fJk1Y^m8KM`Kd451o$; zs6%<436blKFbNOfBBscI6a&Ui;Y@d4!G_)h0+KLs4p0fWer=M`nL?bweK5F!`VV-@ z2UCC1XW);RLb@qD+%eklCkpiJGGT-}Q9_i^)(YZ7q8-F;ZG@r|R<>0H*z8H&JY8i1 zoZcEl1h!DQ1cRf%auMoIiw3l-uD5Je1jYos0&Uno#NSg%3Wf? zg$PU;4FvuHW`9al9wa0Ue}s=j8dhWEi*ef?^o&%YRozsn8eUYHOoE_9+B7=rZ9-~- zT8F6V+mQU@wwYHSSiKO1la3w|K3T|-TJtfItWOdY^JQ&ZB@S8hWlj`zPgf=1((y4_ z`h-ruQed;uFWRJOZ~r9t+0DZ}B3RO-2BRXax%z@?SSfqvnq5_ zIFI8lcqo-6il>aL9?*U~@}6jVMNq{f5bpUSr}nV9aEJPZ_2h}f>;&+!X}gDzS-If+ z_Lj%nz-hJrr?}B>px45JVsN%}*4q=k04QkbK{#-~4w(A>PdKyRKvmrd zZH|zffp>Ae=ny8KLW|5h5g?_5>hs_SeIXN0C;;lbK`B2(r{D-82w_|3jjc{}suS_4 zpC{-b5*e8@B&NlA;mVw2EyE*rkHPS)+>mb5j!FA+J-}H?YdKu? z9%iU$wPAeG!G`!<Ca)few zkP>lAf#Xo@OK?O)5d7vJPX{N*@282rzxP=DBuI@{2%tpDrNa`UQiA01Hxbe8jes6` zVY_ITB)eX+mWG=fdk@dj>!tgGojJ=+GM*;dW`^c3Tj2$$*A3gwN82OXIDOQ#`|#9o zMGBN;Cl0N~Nl{XUsnk9KZ}vy&4>|1E=^m#TDsa}w>ylNqT`l){OP%AaJ6|Bd=Z9cS zoEe1k1-)BA&B<77RkFSK=n|mb(L42Ze0TiqGMx|)15X`oLM9tTZg=v>SMi88om{nq z$&^(titQ)xCFIj-hdvgOi{Q={xQ>MV_oI}V@bun**4jH5P4df~-|;8v3OrD+p#KVz zsEV|xWS1y=LaOu*74LI|^M3Lr(i2go!RBQag#m)Gc_;oKl8Uy^_^77a~(4o@$fLcAbLG`thEngoxeAU1Vt~sMi=G2F45EF-iJ5;b&4A z@s!?|YIm%}8@38xs`IH_BT4c>(Nl7xz(CE5m=T}gkv=7^YLpU5R8h{8JYs%KZPReP z-W`;ZYCIx%A}y{$IxQOo7jUrw(?oFo!Kk8byaqJf0^K{%aEqrCIn9eLrx24`i8|^P z3hi?~0y=lMiES(9g#P>^gjf`*PazTgUwYA&o#rkckneI)CVMc^sNt{%u$Sa{gR5f5 zB7Tk?A~++N#RVXkDOqCdK(YPUgOvF6J`d*gid0@>IG3oDv~Avve);SAGU0O0q&b?M zEgnuYG;ix?*EwkGZ9@`6kwJ@FP=owp8IA!})l_W18?g>``im2ibXxqK!{8 z`Z~DwDU(w1pKS-Se5SrcZ@7y-1Dd3EBN;VJ+O>iU61WEA4+<9dzib@{U{|aK5FYw? zq8^dCKE7V(fTIidp)XL6#6X}XL{^lU(~+K5^#cK&<-TbfVAE?vp`XFrWFzsoD*@ea z5?{Qw<(T$om3F2PCmUY10^#qeE;J1pE?(8lZ|RN~Cxp)X)K3`ftIaiA5!VTBd261Sk7Pw{0+eqknYYPNu|C1epSC;8%Een+GjAl!S9 zNjcHw&|tpA8mxdvwa@zlIg}{aft$V-;bnho>tcLtyY2T%V|pKfAF+Mx&dVFL@=z6v z2WHk|j67P5lIvUAQ=2}t68nJUZfDO=E|T;NtG3$a7FZL*?5 zCRr&wlL-~nJVblzhb0zG6^unWRnPs4J0Pi10(HQ}7)+DE@ds)Vqho)GXuz%TKgT)2 zNTNIP@v480SRcakw}!@Z--KD|V@wkM_xP@cI5!YPgYehMAPL_+C?JW`528r(r5C)R zuXOPSn&wG!>vCpokW^fiL>FL<*czcrT=*nW%ev$GUm`b%?ZD!@E9fU{T|-+&6=~GA zoejlX^kiL$+(eof*CSNKBw>4M`Js^BKV}?7ZbW4uhC7;CnZi1{%7=onljYz6Q~7g% zXfeOt4gSKLg1SK}by%S5zW}FH;{SP(2ti}le_W)XJWw|%!ct?9#flV*PB0%Bgz-oY z6A}ec7zGm>Nbt~uaZ3)jB@DoP4%iAr0nL_!0KdeDT5-YdPC=r5|F|g}f56uJJ1tCb zKcR*}uyhS}p!UDu+nlgS#Pm98JsbaSabp#pT3oFEwZ%n2c?MEmdZb7@4unREcoq63 z5qg)HVE>Vd9U1|;k6=HNx&eC42k?MSP0@rF{m4E8yfdjbz3T)F+yw=b;`luh5d6vw z?Kt{CaOW0mA^ZE?eBT&HbT`Po*+e`V;N)_YuW5()T84$ zlKbAtw1L2&Zj*KTU}Y&71bxbJYW00xd0muqEh^H14x3ET3x7H*Y33VM+iuTALFO)Guyzf@_2UPF$kFdQ@P-j_XYE|o|f+~KwHj0Cr#Au*dqpb(yfv5R!)h<0zW zH4_(jsGOM;VA+b>W*2&k8lORs-9#^e3l^CAmE#W{*1s|EzYe?n|M$cGKZhG7RveY% z(fkS|PX_b%;4#6;2wY*w^Z&E3+?)_B13@U@j{;>d)4B~r2H$ro-T{!rI??|}JE?LA zWDx5MGmKNde#k`Lj{V6jV)?F^AkB1k2aR_#tK6^mUWlBtMdh$|CLy3kc(Q=He$`LJ zZdFZfGYP~=c|Bvny%{?b+elc<&uC4egOErd@{+pWy^8lGl)85uH1QY7xWTMr2Z~9A z%C7u49V#zd4e{RoQmHo&GIlu163TQr>>XzwQ-PnqT@*jmie1LZQ8@sns3~)!u4yyg z))k?DODF(`n+N%A{PX5>|9(UFZ$KH`6QB(H7XTakKUYW`Pil1k`wEHu!SrsR^XL)% z_7Pe{E&d)lvCibKtMj2a2!tv-&4xz_1Od*-Os?RmiA6RZ;UathLqUK?)5JhHwjq=g z`<}-~;r+))@xP&D!p?T;;Epo58j=0?zc(}SFGY@UX*H0@!jm9}qT78bjv0(Pf}U>F z8$CVx#aAHq7EVGUr=*PEJ9>JL?xTZ|ci%D_%cV0-jRkgOzv2sGe0$qAPB&{9m8H5n zb~q^7Ysb5vUM6JcDeT$QH%ZB(lYH~pz7;L#fGcHdT)67$pJ>k0U}xNobKcw+{ntWSDgYBu^~+EUu?g2P(Tu4_5tl$;SS_E`fkfgU}(P-C+L*#brR?k&H30&DLlG$XhoB>X%Yvm+Yh@x(~k#cTSnK77M7SQ zEwZGBtNS#cwS>afxlctUS77l^z4AoBe)!r8+vfPaz*02(42C)-Is;s&z!jK(Py|$t z*VsWlO+y}=)=ZFo!iK%Wm$|^3TOGX2llO~=-uRQ;b z6rEah4QKT>J@Dpc66d{Z0{L0cZARQ`co8~hp_?nKPjPXhCy`dc)=N1x^PS`}+D}IQ ztg@)Z$`!J4SCXy|a$lk#wFgA@JrNTR+a>fp)lEXDeD~y49oD9}Dfr5--x0sgm?bs->mtwxf3%oDU9I_aPQ<9({(8 z_AcK}xk>_`LkwP7gInZ++(Z7EZvKGb4SY8DuZ=aFDTqYyE8Cd=XSR9v-xt>Gk0uXC zkCAuTkHRnaA0FvTtRIh8giptz9|;4W-C5tEcB8n9yzIHk27y}1i5|p#M^NfO;x~a# ze=|e|FI2$sLqSs0|M$tC3<-UjYsyFc628}63x^DM4F?T(4GoL3k50zU{vg~5k@7boKAboejY zaQJFt0fIsi@n9~7R)@<&boUXw`rD+y+IFGAT+66_sz2ePR~Z45PJn;jc@$5IHhWN@Dh zrfB5+1HTzVknt#}>VjR-g@S{de3t17`K{suBvTjpUqu%}2*`y_uT}bE-N=*r6&}T& zLofHdU*9{PPwm@-QDVDl`iUfo`;$g1gv0FA48m`}VM=qH;0_^NkMs_%^BID=!;?uf z1*q$=*^qA3e(b5|=Fh8kUj+H?;zF?WRhZaA@a`2sVDP?iF9EpGI&mf-zKkoaPZwJo zNt+x`yV-3MaN24IN#@YuoM*S3k!kqpMJ7y**wH?|q!so*ugdJRjg|LA&GOvQtST8km78|nq`C_OWBrx`YKrbnY|lGLLnhq^c` zcukfdKj8{Tn65yKZ$k%l_1Qqq#xk+?b9BQR5Oo9l=dq@|6?V(VF5FZ?kGg_{{hQ?>};@iB*(_|;F z)5BJ??OnecwJdVGG}OOfThbRdp7Buop+;^bY_psk=w>hdpw+T*%YS)#f2$M_73$lV)lq4|MKHX7FVpC1fG7nI_>#O;tZfX_D1M;PNCvH6`J6 zlB2w^5hW@4%Lh>u{`sxdlv4Z(+%6x`Qqc(!cdj3o$PppHof}M zG22wsx!;dG=v^w;DabB6y-#d+a-Z6v>1b;gPBJpebe8bxYs7rVFQ;uV7hX1;8-V)K zr3#8x>lMZ&gf&FdVY@FxSSB7_XLom<5@!X!>qaN9^z1JFXAcL#;>Podvd^lHn`VYi z6Rn8w0WmREM)(cuynE*dAF$@1-&nJ=@4x2>_?&e}(D4CYPNT3FeF1g6{q8+Emurfm z5yh0Z+}s(o{-_QZe`O931@a#+J_q0LI2>d8D4Xcz<@{Sl7EqF( zlUM8g1e5NX6pejb=iWqa&>h&6OJ+055Sf0Ya>|jjvF4U8$|_etqxy<%e~>sp@~jWGO+S`AqZ z-VezbQgww%2DUf25rCTr^H8e6qNZ!ieKm9Q8CzGDib=CdbZTDa4T1Ga?E6WvQ;^mh zbjh$@4w&Nw&PS62qz&=g^RZtH%xVZTY!K`T_^*+HIn{s8$B6$s?1_K?g@AxS2sCSk z;s9a{Lmxk)qdbaU@nO_LU-zJ%K0@4_qKn^yrevmn^Dal+j6}eF6PV(a^ACDu!-+1r za1oFRva%Hg31uTIuK3arGg^)WTf9u!!Hg=_#!4~V zmU)c1RvvE5BE>5Tx3Jm(0DD5_YTTgmKs!3ZCRHk0cZ0o)sc8ggWbL#JpDOL6nb>i|XLTRRB^g zKGyW6TVuCN{M1Z&alF02QqjvkU*7B15 z_lt|diBUUH-PL&DD3tyb?d@1A&QVigHi+u2*5S* zkeqN*6%@H@5wZfRWw~V1M^3~T<26>L6rn8om3D-spHB^P@gz&WWat$l`gcx4HWjs_BH{l{y^2@-Am-Ms#0{8v?v$PmUb z0xR(Y=CGeSLk!^x8l+PC5kpi(9<-)s&FTaeo)Yl|7fe$UWcP~Ie7sK0{N@kb<8wcF zg(t1|!3(v9STFUNm$hdx`F$Du6y>j)gvud5S9Is@dq(1xkCiYzE6-A}p9G@$ znq@}GIVWO#nWCpbI-Df6;*0$#5Sn0|4}Z83-i7PvI7`Tf&xoDcQ7IO~Sbb+nthIbo zeR6^DwJuo5)M}qY*gp1cDP~V^n3UO?r<6g6)yp=$Od(>tu544+l2^AB3D=0Z1JYvu zJZzlcjNkq!TB9{~-B0$j!Ui@gDkI2Ie99BP)3n^77%Ir4DkaI{J2M_Q8jLOJAV+Bg z{~#+j1lhn>;)UvOe|84`yjFJcT*q=J+F_p!JDuI}rDl4iUZk{sd$?myv2L($u&%LB zWnOcg9PojM+-zVRJFZvhoJQ@E@mj+fbp^?Pu_p?xI-g3zEfU($hmJ`d>U$SX-B~Gv ze}54|iSe0|3n2pQXSGG)uehG9wmz#>p^q0a=9>QG!S>%~JKJ}bctmC&xbscl9V^d= zaoIo}-qf2WXb*|A0+aZbxCB2&VjS!>D0e+vEGzzm8I3#Fk?bSVY5tez4 zyB7|-_Zrq$hj>o?Xw3)JZZ1@%`TH5;T&>ZL&jOoaLJZVPQ5?fih7S>xMJt>Zu&nye zOn~r2)w&yBOn{$%7Hxad%3bdEw9|bRTJA)1P)uB@Y}b9w39N`HU^LuJtMTykzknLH zFwsRlp-kpEfoHmeU;}q5z*Sv;Fgkg%a0YGhAyi<|gZ1wa+u5R+w4RkES_-F%>af|Zhyf?Z4HLUKe~^7fTK?!?}05I zD9qQ|=q9^%QeS!#Q6}9sC{~-A8-AU*>pXMq#HA2JYKtD9e#mlQ1D$T|$N(G$(B7krmxfaqIr$?tG`O&WDZGHset!}2<;g6RodEs_3oeP(A9@Fw{w#tY z9y{q&!Gays*z=a=hf48ad)0xSK`3*0F_yZ*Wof7`S(@hcfH^g!`#@YX&jw6^ACy0e ziCKHc{Kl?pa~w4`^ruZSp0!`^yg8K5_(tqt>+!8|qTXUjj&;4#)moCvCcd0bKh!i44*Q>}z zhAAE5DNRaXjSYPdkV4f6FPtswvD%E;16I+_N295<~EAdVXL6kvyD(o%nQ?? z7i3KmvSxR$2xY`k*`T!1yh@>~hI&t}Ccfg%qLG(-*ZbaJFjI|Nc)alQtBL8PS9oP* zooc7JZyR2KARtWl2^#QUsFO_fZ(o@a+9@b$_AG`yPbz5eZH`kGlS;p;4w!TF^HUns zA);l+7qyCcK#F!R2pM71w)RM?NsIVkHM*@S`*WKo72DPk+%E`bh|2W`9sHZ=w&*3$ z#aQ8Bg|RzBm_nv*c-!fa0bD}2h!IgMM9`+uHhR526+Y;g>Ww29B9Gsn{F>|JFjH6N zQ}t~n%XqBR)aud2x9|0bZN9axk+bftv;IHN(Ayjh@7!7q11=6!jmh0l`wsNK`9)p2 zyWVYQWd{gtZ{1AC?YX(`wR?PMn;X!FhX`0>gHe%y)unv(x%2JE`UM@#dfx?7G%X9ox^zkj_@2!|!FcSyb!+4IH|)VkNzUpP`F=4Bg=_!kr?h?`y(IVQHb1iPW0^ zxIoa{8<41Z6j~7ifAglg)8$RZP<8VMH!*XUG)}U9zt&N&nZj)Sf`d+B z4&z1nL=AXxT_gco3?XkoBUdDk8=Fh|TLgW*u!=_bg|DF)XktjKa2_kSp1axJ6UpP$ zwrRqtRA%wEqfOGO_X0_hD?-}(3Tik%uQkd0Vun=zL!_8#;P2G%1q*&9|cYRa6T zrsyBFEbtFnfy}AVr}-ho3Zfv4%g&e3v`;||=hX|6)u1WtU#vp9r{;4g{A_aforGWT z`KgQDJ5S-Sia+ov%O4om}+m0h0uAqA7k%@jbE(YLUlA^{bZU&Ia9k zgu4(!=?C~h#~cCo&whzVVmX{baPxUS^Is9v8M%Gkb6CA1os|7IE1~cG_)YYN4SveA z|HM-m*H&qje)TXl^=trrSN#GIPwdPp1gYXU@)_Kb1~)1Hx9He^=h9cc=6{mskDznG zv?W>&8i57Kii!o}*y>WN0YsmcX;_FDGG7;@hgJPx-s)GF31q?45pP#-_>FxM$m*z6 zT8v^e;g?mx&%Mk0lNgf_f zVXsl?+!6dwBc$)yU1jlA#HVml6f?velH+qEwRy2JR}JdI;%pFwY+*mkMrOR&;jl$v zgxTp*a8#;Xu}o;Zf`xw93}(vpBxd`MTk$8NOPkYw%`=~DvBLH5AagHaX(zRokm^GS zVKPa2Wl2eK4DE$0v!|4|=X1|S!sE}OqY*t5c8bLfZM<{hjkeq28^N^k6)r%v>4}C0tIX}tl0^X_)kJ=mAQersj{EZ#VP9+_9V=F z@3azWYy=qX%?}Wmq^H!MpJa8DR=-9bnE5X0_me$<$0$mgZ={6$Vh(0zywG`0hKhhonbJ-t5TsWqMM zrb7tIj__sZ!tah))=sq?m8HW(V!OSW3^@pS4QN}85$f%I^}V7Zp($bwF8Q=_=@E}r zF#I@>lQIr(1q_ni_;E1pJ1|j>SwWVVku|;p-+8nKY}!QQI4UJ%&k(;<+M?pp{Zw-c zwh0--$jsAM*al4Uw|tgR0-hV^Tu8fg6gY$l!Rf)5`7*u>{`9t(2(XMM0b4AgqrP@~ z5LH4I`04!?b_xG3$uy>Hb#6qTc^p>XY$ZX^V!<8GdWz{mXJHaK5*d;x5(5jlG}SK9g%lcyy>Cn@-avd}^-=%b0IJbA-Fay*=D`R>Xy)m?>LiGOn&J4lux} zSUuw?ADNo^c9S1Q3ZD& zu)P6L+TG5fZ>s+b(n^VDg<+l?kONp-0}#ku8A3?|0@rTi8l=(OKkhUR+CQ&za}Le= z?xavzuVYR?k)1RrDm3$TFdy>(|t;uknYxf550p}CO z?Oy9g4K;d|kBMrH2B{+n>DB5{>iIs$0t#+1S_&i(yHoV#2j!EPom2MnrBi$??y_!h zu{kMaZoXLCOx1h(L+CUQHlT!h)zI23$F#Qri|Ws6&y@x<0(i4*IG;#b&#tQ5N1*x7znYxN)AGgJw5`=f1zZD zrC#lT`$jOGD3J5_m-wKQ@#N40e-ws;JiSk4k=;o>km(t2up;ocwl!XKNT2A5jdzNF z7&dYvFX!PLik-xVk0*fDx1$4r9-d8oXF2c7)JPZ2IaI$CXf)yqboyDr%LN`dd|T=% z3tm$jwN`oGVoIL@JU_eggYVnD)6rC^_@Y_(`Gw6aqimz>6(aR&mYlBaa9NvP6;-Mg6h4puGBC zZp|ZO{6$3|{(CMbNOD|V>~3&B379VS$tB}=OWyzM*nzx-seb9IVuo}LtGH!t9Z>FJz3rS13U}}q8i)!_?XD?i*LJ0 zQ(O=3Tfp>le?sa0b-W-}_|%vcl6lx~VYZ$mMmaxdwn}06L|42-V8V02 z-@9>uYaKY7WkkKFlLZb^=(~|@aQ@Gx6RLt6ggw+Eh55@`Gd&*?E@U6+ zuCq>8iHG+mO1mk>C<$o=;wKERs(#Wd8Ay=XP(8Nz7eoR=5kO5B2oD->(klWN=I!yO#1P{}AzDNGa%#4~ zo$jo^BHvb4#eVoSPZnKW-puB_WaL6pbkbSMG}%tg`y^JnPr8oy1u>V9bOn)j=}vc& zn~9hNVHXf0x}i(6luRElE-I@p<|s8yjlJE2mLP(;{Q+2}jvgWdf@5(O?&r^;a*44s z^)kz)-iE$g372a4a`1Mg9m9~kEI@6`I8fF5fLQfDJuc(IsQF|`0eTB`ef&iW zxL|?lmj1-B_{kR(WR)Ia=w7l>n4r=DQ773Vl}Sk&DFIKNM)1U@Swh_UmmDXtV+rew zl9ST&u(Xo0jdJtiSC7keZ%1)8>+)hUMxqtOtGFF%Y~Pwl_Fuhu>uKPrBcwKM=G_`r zvwyg4et8|SdGnBA$INr4p?)6wEdm1Ix|03x_9G%|lVb3GlN?z)r4J4iJ52>$1QYc*t% z>-MIc$z>oU{>oAIQIB``D%G7!*L>VW2|`U|Zkzc2DNhMrnbO*MhBA(ZqUNR;3j0k- zMU2bg49hOLyT(~si;{oI7>ZHfJ2dhmWQ?7m7;xbR)A;~7|CYx7@14))FBLJm0)&^Y z3Du`i8DZNrZ-P(%LMoGJ+1cjO>mUq)43thlxuA&G<9+5`Grw|tEj9}E-825vQT9{I zg;mvPOr>LhEW13rV1KKQV42(JK&sgMijG!)m0GdzxilqBuR~T19fOtAX^;xJ_1j{C za;Nwhf_!4l5ljJSAxL3J!oh1;zysDo{M~G^oQ<0J0)j2XXfRniPtZ^jwEXnP5c#2H zJ}I2jgvCCmj}H~^3CQbHTsTQLnez{1l#tx`6O%oPvtsLPrSt4h=1O*l^z(h-A-OvW zr|w7>TW@`;Y%8`Jm4rvW$Mb(A{(93OPtn?Z`Ubt1I8*+;@$(-|%+ATkvk}uFg%dA~ zW!_<@z6f)pp;QP)lu##5C@HtkDJY_I-kG=$Eco<|_9OH}P^)Yv?yj6a7{Mh@ z4lunDC;RVjzYhMThzF8H0M&*!a9dfO4dUe>BJclO9HvUkIy+6rqxE^&(sd=^vnSpS z3VROIobmf-3m|#J3+}?zT{uSu4+*$(qnESvGqkuO`MC|e&wHn|T`lY|5mzj}#+3`( z$jqULpoc^P+n|-GnN$C^>l=So*rsvN@+5Mnx$ecN?szj_0SsyBiA8O z2xzNU`aSil$71L4w~n8MjiWLcBu53V&G*z_Ttku+^7hcFOQ(SGf8YdJ=KZ7o`x75M z`$=U`kAwqvROO~RNGmPFnv;pQZ5hcsyFM|? zjoI0HOUq{bU_V$a;v9s!e9Su%5uISg6DJRf zHR&YJjXP_Kt(#|KzmknbK65UT;Shf$3HwgtXBJd}iNy&W@o7T^2@oym_kkcq^~Q3| z%zl?UHd!tGGYn!P(V44Cw4rksxQjY2EzDdPq~*6_0NIhbUrOZ&t0Q? z$d=ZMS76cyIA23fkRk5x7Dm6sJ0Mn=NRfE9k)ysN+YrsziQ?Qr0{>>_wJZvOIOhoy zlS66bFf62Q&L^n}21%jotSfPe$;yglu68`HZXxaY$ZBxQDyqgveH$0nRRH>GOcKw& zcw3lBfnfZRFL}u^rJohODXW*_pbf%GyUN%dIE!h*a}MnD?(y%bO=004?!+P_v89*C z^-Pr9uzTQWI(9rZ<7R^0fUwn8>{mW}E{UjdR)W24tG2y+ZS6Es+s>D6+pXvhRP zEclj2450+WdIWiT^BMzOoWS%gf3l(d%LM!hL-;i9IDsKw~FZ9Sfy`5yCYrknebjj#0c) zQ35fhkiA1PUOY_p-it#N{XNVaSqrfYHjWgH&5(gkG;XN@eQKf5=LymzYR=T5Xr2D@ zmxAk6)TJ#~gN^$%&8jP=+NMIokUzf_eVeB? zugG=quBnltl6X>Ah^F*iK(H;6ycdM0=5YkLXo2g1{(uPPKRzxOrh+qY%)}bjI)R^f z{7IzLVw)192+;+Ts~m5#Ob6eroH8(CFv)QlRio z`htd`int26*mH5lxuLJY()h@;Cu2I}!QZLPYhd*pS$*0#W^LC>o*u3QDYQlOd^=9@;ksZ&ELBxmAx<9QfF!pT|W1gcTv zVoXSg_;$QKVK~WpOoETqDg%VH1@8(THWZ?9tW}~kCr+=@;T)5AoZ!NBn)5qw9BBCn z$j$|2SH^{REA8qv7AhI+-XdjiAA5PL54GLFrlMvTfcqK1bUj?0zmH*wn;N(K3KD-h z!u7@2r|=2JI6$tOqUH9W0LZA9pod?8bY2)nIab187LzX~Q+O5<@l}Q>LXhm+312Y7 zLmhYZToMyLUK9MVA|IyGU!=P2(*1#UaF=|4FjDWl3AHyhX1!;Puf1hq8*Pk-u5gU% ztIpi<_3OJ?y;3q1g-J|qNQOG(Uax#6f<0m6}zcW zaU|u>qc~%uQM2A&^pG@ctvcqaC#5`I%A`f|JWZo}1AIpa`Z$5W-7)Q#W9-^3v2x`j)46uCDV z1#HFw(qWik7jU*I@jYomuUIY zqKx&O{_XkoecAArZ*K~})cY3<(tWG2kKu)~SR$7c*@wh2gI95a|AZh_O&ZkW5i5|* zyP?z!u|nH~`_dLT&%coX-$jG^*;JHGlg&nkYlnnvuoim+Ar4~)q6iH){WOS_ndGDQ z`szZH6vOhwwl3?UhLPHTw@FFr(>7_da=y}*o+Y<6Qs^0 z6mr~X3rIy@3pl1gT|2elyj9NeDMwotgQX{^y~!eJSMy?g1E9b_z+rONlPEQkQIc&J zW!Wz2jU&P^Mz~=t%rUa%3b_hsoCxEtMwscOq>mzJrKyI)dsY9OCCZq8w{|JXlP@uHK- zF|sba41h^s^yF8qqAD+sN{xVnfw6{-fdNxpOWe(&G|{mS;bBgXgepx*{YWf^2@7jp z{fvek4tYk5GHBO9NhA>igPIW$D;Wm^0tpF0<_=aOk2+Y+#IuQ1B?i4DUP5FN!b7qk z1|R7VqQ_+K?i^tw$O%dm3(HKPqdWLyOa+GoN(!RBlYn4`P#+V@1BwVh;Y8oRN6x@o zU`h}hLoM7983|85PdFMW!8ho10wK6UK%hb%9g(+`>(QA_1zq1YHX)pU3^^Yh!OnZr z*aKmka14>3BT~_Yh!#vaF^|C$Mv4R5s|8O~VhiPNkQ23RGP(>wwvs&z8FD4^D0@kF zV@=7srp-5C(R)#OB0QfI~opz59?3V;_Y1TkkqFX~LezL%#a* zoS=lV3LeIs?hZ&!6cW;EGT~>_G(Apu9az+5RLj||gt@biB55)alzq?8rK*B(@xATp zk@=DWYA5*Udd~t~dVb-Nq-Sh2d>H}K(>=6|;l9g6F{r~HO$9|oLc~Bp#sCMw9ac<` zg8d;I7NyM~r{jH2w$(mLfDo$;evY6AN(uQAS@b>RRZiET3IJ{s?)>!nXMA851OQ_K z4Xq2pJ{QdiX65I;4shn-lCU)pX9?SeBB+oYf&S?9G@Fizxo1BSfv&1!wL@#9>ZL`V z_j2Ox_~4^6BRxPcSm=`&08o_^1%W{gphv>#5xTkuCa@Ab6r%@sn18{zka^krGoS|l zTzmX5P^R-(n&N$DAnml2St&BC%iXA(JR~M0!Ugi#4r7lOWu~1ve1lXZ)hS!B zh^L4Mj}1MOj84iWnXDwx!S_X@j;)i*U3^`bDu&cV52v`Haab5vZ_&#+2gUbaz{G8C zIpPz6}qYTW-)lt2#MYn{3vAtCH524HxVMl_!fHHZTAovQxUqmN;QB*LnhInv1 zQpBv9LS%m=K*X0C>Bw~wus?f^DQq7UxDnozt1{o+fe_4cGk5*AH&;cO9)_JSB1|Tn zcQ%YGuqvtebj6S?vAsR{=9@;MXHF*(`E;Sc%Tt=~0HC>CzJ}!qi%j2QjiP?nx$o@K zRq(hP%d|Y(s^cdG#usP`4ax(o9jo!wS0vN5v6wt78yVD0>~eVdElzHPc`}QL76&9P zDD$uUf6lroQF|@r(yL;squb9q*jF(QO%xQoW&f@>F~GHWLBtwEqP9G0UmUDS}j$iyHbyZO#r^R>TgjJs)LPNLgt&!}NRN=7#*`&8e&FvPD zlU!fZMN$sB(!k2!PNd4r$ZQ?0ev@wxRec~zY0pPQ(8BLk|UdJ81V!Vh$e1NM9t!gL5kwfYtBD7X}R zFWMoJ&2ET zH#+t3Oo06v$E{eFa02dSyAN;lbl&?zVQxGDbJD9yyC^->94!G|gT6mU3_nfD0VRF@ zxtvu`;6byIWIWLKdpaOwTZUnSdXct?mCGQ3ae?;RfVuakzSn$0R==aqyU1Sv)M)(N zlaLIq>6u6bOP+ox3^4-+fj#oJ(vy^yp*7p0EZwy7zT>-mO}ki8GWnc|B`;4LW0s?v z^De`asm>$REFi6ly4bZ2X1r8$mYjv3=uz5zN%+t-UDua4$}l0**3^HgA&~eb`Ktr= zxTU{kD6@aryNpmKvT5&gs^4UQ`l{Ao%+hh3e*A3PXI2P%a^Rc`$`e!sQC${>u4`Yqz7`rj@5h2klgtA&#N%Bk#)5w@HHbZ=+W zco-h`Ee#5sJ~*Rw60 z!Vt2S%`Q2PBPX})6B4phT`ECIg+ft;i^>~PE%V!cxzxv+Fs|A~ypk<|OC^Y}xF!ZB zGMG}F#d2#zZluDm!%m-2;pF~R(ADS~LJa0)u(9>D3xXz8Ap$U_nV3^)Wa9kAp;AM$ z)<|BEb;L~<77jDg*ZVahWD8KTY3B&}`#Z&%geifcMT#SjY3VV^P3!oEPog&}9Is_) zk#p<~n-J3nI_PnIx#6}WJLb}c>reJj;%xgmN&x-lgn z(U6m3N^lCBSL4CyqHc*<2l`&aw^bJplmCe+^!0R9KB@|etQy~9ppThec+Co9Dcby? zoK=gcNH!-xzcBUEedcN(f+=vr8ZVuD&C85G_Sr7c3=I!OqL?-nCC_FjyC3 zXlKVT=i!Z;!7{RAZ4q`ve_9a7x_-C3YBkqcYany|YiPk))r&Sw#@=kU%#0H9& zm8D8;#3W1}ZpBK60*h&WJ9g6iVIG)=$15R#i`|HA$74XUW~DEY75--J=1S&+T+9LH z;IIG7v`gsMW$NQKZf1Z!R&fAK)U)Vy#n599-v)zJfSGkc)@hN$cXU+=3+!SI zNGe+4Az_ZfgQm5o`OJ|-CnuFcva@CB!9!*%| zPX=CHavK>k0j*-E92%e3RKm45mGW8lTwq0<8p1EfHxqyDxUP9B-Hd7rJ;hwnARtzi zEoZI3VNN|6H2UX^E%d~YsrNO-{Q|j4j+OdYnz zh&?O(M%-=zq@p2H3-avIv05iV==RntgW0^tSMUh5?5?4Dx@Ary9SOx9VpC3D z=dJ^XEhS-GOo(|Uw)stOO+)f|x6v`ulxzQ6Z4qh-9(c=zpGKiQo-|Jgav~s;Gh@D%LA-f9?pu-Zg;7;& zY*WoqoCbR*e^u%EyyPfBr6uopICRwE>{8n|*XVAm9Jy;a(?THBqqXY5f~I)1Me;>E zu1}nn9}KD8|3ZJ=$0^B^{b{C$cbZZ1RjqqzKXSSoG;19VH-HQOyjt(?X{y;eG&#Ay z5=hi!;YN?d-`j$f3IgH@3_YebJv2I065KuU$xI)E@_*46ve+EoDJl)fWZ%xLo4US} zF_L?V^<03t?^R3(|5(Z>5_xPSzTnF2i+)00@7*$2$=~5RBViU7p)Y^RiX!2Jda{}) zmGHb?36;C2>rz{H8ddzs+$$cH@7(G|`U$6q^^$mg2JQBHbMFf$Ua{n5= zf)X4;{IfV!&);oj;o|{!5d$rvb<)H)RL9ZvKqMGurx*k>YyL*fepB1RxIO(xe@}mU z7fb0QkW14t2g#MQsr^ddA7(htU`a~%`mV2|SLYx;Xx9^RXkTY6rKV(z>w89@cEkG@ zsNvL_Q_|~oMq|}CNy@E(j#>;f(M5s~gxSzgYE1)IpO!045si+R@IUret+7v3Nn4tH z^qbwzRtF^~1xt++$&czt7FmD^ zVAEfZE&nRn*WkrG5@uTJXGr?aau3ClB%KK2FoE@>)D<(%i3o(`IUXOWcz?R|NB^ig zdW(w{{t4m^`M_h|yg9Z~X*cnN*`O^i7Ie8k6yaP$57Xf2*DUgSl-Jf@kS+zVY*%(A zby+jVAt|iI`+8`8KIH_+CnpzNO=;SA zOh3&wH859vzTmkwFu(Qn9;d=oUojPCef{Q8>!%pV%(GoOtmXbrcdhbm`C%$XYtsR> zm@!v;$!R}+gWRH7_omJeKx4{SvhD2=G3HJM zqf4oG{~n@FIR_-&uPJwUWi)C3ACZhar6nx-c}Im>)DteD)>p zXv0AMN39s~Y<#FhXjp+X9Ldv~XXkGN??X!0brKEf``ah_J@ad|MfJ?)uX%Uh6eZmj zLVq`&a`SfOIkKQ%XHUDB_NYJ%HnNx9hCS?HJJU3%HBnKBl&;+C|MkKN3&k&)V z*zb$3>PQr9Nq%?9I3Z%Z0%73t_@k@<*~V^JT%$=O8b3b+o~TcFuiN(Uo)gl?U=v+Y zS_E4<|9Yh0CfzOIbCStXMFmnb=e)|wl&|b&^b130pIZQaGv!aE$WT4}?6+gD|GF%! z;;g~5=o2NVMau|x)RkgngdIRn>DU#2x|zBNgP5BJ@)Sr?t>*RIO@l?okwSe;aKIY> z@$+XAA2duy*hX8RM|T(E!MmxLP3UK7-}57bT?6bjmwmPRhf@OFl*{N<(%xElO`7ZF z%go9SypFVEQC>6crw9kTv$2&1lk8C(F{~H>$7mxU0 zO_p&d7wzJK(9m@g9u*f9;LTOL%0RW?}YA%vq>9psW@^yi&f6O*YZqG?C`1S zgLOx^tVBBpdvExt8~1kB=|Lm^E{KjtRE8iK3oRWi`FlRHQXrs_1|GHB$?dP+8F+Zg zU-PdB)s97eh;Zn`c8@@*f~??xCymoe&`3Jz&KeJ?j^VJ$W}C?Eiwl@O+?V@X=`M_f~;c0OE;UeR(jrClY%# zgeJ-1;q7Z?Ho6?B+Z82oN6*HuJD0g=KJZ&e5kL_w7N1dSDSaW& zr@Wm6O(!Im4TmaqD=b7ck5-=YbU+dJ`Y4cn&S>|DF*j+=hsVA-U?=8w?G~l+KxS(&jVFaATr8 zTg`71hoV;-X+vxyXRz2Hez%@uulHdI$2^G7%3$OucFEq>5mbEmi1Tcv8@BBTOBGWP`l{^w-L+;7P;xlHPGYhrG2(y2z_a6w9k{}`1IL`+*Z4z zIVRC)`se9mD|Nzr4rdKzw~#&+ru zzM60{89(O}0W$>AWKhL#x$gx<@=Q%w=li6B%{ni;zq}x+OSj$x2?|G8D!qQRB`U3B z9oOt6=BSK0PK4O`*<7s{vRTh;XE~@D1?;O?Q@!Vrj#3CXO7rJ30!8p#l0bisUogUE zkKN24lSw-lFUeQA?*QL>U}4!naY8P=$QBo{{#D6v_U z8Y00wjmSyLluIUsif;HhI?6k zuZAi%OCch`a~z^WmD`ULXa}VGV^`*Riz>o3TP`qzz$gyWfW`kA!{l`1=6 zSkfB(q-nyy5_((w9`@Y}G{sDm>@!3hB}3%O^XJk2 z0gga-@F@6`s(Uw|w}jgM=_kJljEmQAym5)6iV@b9T({$f=w|z`8xS%brKH%{dD$q6htFn+F_LbtFptzpjNhx7fdzY2F9HtKgv zUt!rqmJxR)R-I)SWya1Oe-WomU~WuN4bp0va_6E%%gmtRQv1goci+%d?~G@F333aF zGZ1|NXb0&O#FRST-v}{%t*uDY=*z5ms?Y<_o~w^`^eg!pz;~5<2~_$UO$nbWW1Bs& zn(lw*)gDN=6KxII4(sX&;+a9KN6uyj8d06L0tvv8#pRN%wHyRu+ zHr2~$(%pRkY8r^eW}6Iw^N42QaO!r^>92)#K7zBC1tAu>>Pj0v*jKz_&z4pXdF#`4 z2aJmWyy&U-7UpMIW{ST4W>8P|mN?_D8IGnaSQv1^vhuw{^9XS_Uw2d$;;%{U)onuT z@-rDZgbr*Y>bV6yN#Ey+4({fn26R*LBER;VscYQ%K(R5md#!I%B;dR2z`Zvg*cEbh z76$1nnW9AL&NrJG@;+r zH6z;Q4cAeb4BN=eVlwY+>$$qGo3K;1uYSTLXhGzF4Wu4k@Nn=egEr1mHm1r6)#Xr^ zFy~4jva_^e0{F7%1sW|aBc&~x7u_;_d`s-CE5<1$eL~vFt&{-Z{dC;!DM!X|(W@Z_ z@~YBe8B?Q0&Z3mj)W?xK{zQ`8!2)fF{-b7BE(HC1ECS!JNnUy-e@OaWCL(ksrN{+} z?S0))^VlLZY9Bb1e_Hxctk(W6s&>(KgfeW$7Axy)DG6j5wNjKKv6vOb%!6vX+v1sz zWW26?%R{W?IWl{e)_O6Sm5!$+oocXSoWs`oQruQ@4I2Q1cDln@(`+ahXfN=d9aq}l zRmeM$|I|i-dKES;g>{F4;Jyu_nbyew=PqB-wEBN=rg-O;?anVQe}Yuki6#pEdNrbI z#G*^R7t!@8tNfnUw)9lqNs5zsbPiI9zBjg6mDvmURQaXd?BB%pK7_>nhtVeD2C{N= zp`~L{w+7h(KkjO7rZzw`(8rUQ3(y4g@lM`E9jHy}VGXh(weoTTy0`!>NS#c~Y)veI zbS%m)j^=J=Ko?pkbBhlc6B{!pD>EA(9g7^$%fr#d+?AFN;a^{}c61Oo0Rc&A#rZ#& zg}kghtRLJu4h~LkCRQFAR#uu1oPwkIe}bsHm^e8B%}H4#P3&BO2rSC#657m?ZgzI2 zCJqij7gAbvD{EKMkLzFdFp_ElU0gqgCgose<7DIFW9Q~#VrS<5Z#zHmA9Itpb_bIF zV-$-x(A3(*fsWMH$pmEO3N#^g|F7=c%pAy6Nc13mW7l>$<#&- zWRJk2NXp6gPw3Od6-3Ix`#*tEcHaM%=>N}w(K=mwM*<%7w@Ra~7&c@b=Lf}H+E`vN zSL1^&=TV)9q)9uwUz4H1ZWQf~V22L~oQ(VN8QBI;M_ z<&hX6wq^`~yJOOF`4?8FN@&TD^<1{ljb1oc44)fiAR?VMgeA~Pm zJF=^4luNf={A*L&3}2ZmDd`D8J)eCua~}cAHPMXRcdPx+;Ei{*`7f#ET0z|ij3nph zLd3B*jKyQd*-7l<$oLkk@hzQ%P!rGJtHXADYv7z2>Br=FlfC4kf$J<@5FpOiD}T3F z|8_Jj*0BskwpZ47KZ;}Am}R7%Gu)^TmEWNHfi!!$SSC|4+JXQ>HBFKL>Pag)W@! zx7#MvDF_90&Mnye-Y-|E0WO8v^6z}l>`L_`JNo0?_lVj1q*R-Vm!OvG0Y)%?nrN&i zJZfa*J#IM%0Yl60=@k~%JKMNRZHBAnPrKiZ3Pbgi5vw;v*nv{X-J>1A?n4c<}^E>n8M1I?a{rPE=}< z+}vpQagM8Kt;r=PVMtm<1RgTcj=2(;{CM*rsrrMOrHwoia~;M2r?^&urJu`*?2etP zFl9@s{po!*NHAOGbU~R>sYrSVXL5L>7UJaE7>vb((LN)&A$Et1KkDimyjcA?x_c3wtAT@8|Iyb>YW)5s^|YMm2EEAzQ;fO;EyKYx84oVp53~Mx;QeN!*E6WL zEcPAOnsYZ!spOO1DtYsjFCis(u?KB%XVc|qdEm<|>v9MUD@CWe7!PG&h#C;o_>XmMO4)=c?)xtyt#eofsrE zikphjD2gPHaZ60;eBfS!!Ppl&4=u+NEN)i9ij=lk>i;VWuNtFAEtvYtN9Hz-O(PcA z^4cqFAy36)n9t;SPz*?md5qlLJ*TtZ2Dc%onU&D%Wc=-t9ZK&ha>ct$_;wuHJ-*F% z8lgc(0lr#0k$G~(Iy>1vl(`Cs!~U$p|NA50NfNEqKl6HXI#REAk{Bl4SAe)W+5+H< z2w#am5;r8Q2C<)E^8hV2FznpPu`2WzV=q-KM5a`` zo zpZ*L})+P+i41%Tg@@y)H?g&=guXQZ`0@|5(ZU8a<;Y zvJDVops%aa0HFOSsH^hodVrj;$3~&n%VSnQGq9F=O`gJ5a?FU=rtHg4DXzBpm!;gV z-0lc-@>xw*3Ugc@%Kcj?Y`S%%a(ke79&~FPljP+kNKr8WEvsM%exVn_+7;wn>eyBz zj6L!ImyIiLr3rCMjE!J_e}Q*(7m3p`{HJ{GIgHP5vT90js6D0GsKzv^0J2W%U*4kM zUZudnovyI;RO0GNa1bOP#b=MnD~LY;w31?muL5NQ42xOn(YRh_s(gmK0GV;nZeEd% zJh4q>|8Cb~wqWCjkQ9#3^(F!QH(4%gIrV(Gm0b0d29rC3Z5V~-(Jy77QUZ{569Gm9 zvsVza!5xf2^X->r&?5op2%YzE8t61xD7S^nY_G&28UPaOy8lHHoDB+IOo*m^XFR%m zmdRnV#I0xzP_|d2?x%mr(UuY@)3ix(qpcg@PqZoTu|ZyZWPZOEX51r1p-Eem6Z;Os zc+$DyG&6O}5%pj!o%F~2_*=;roMCViqM7RU&rISLK>)-g%<17vGtQnPJtQeS9od}? z^8rs2xJ1E!@IIm7+5ZiDcc$j_h@yz?D*(UnEnnQ8#@#-INdto<+g%}?)l8$7R9KUT}O-VHv zivA{?nLQoi7t=uMG9oDeeD~oN*bbnSLvdg9m+Su42xCZ>$a{J|MaV{KC#DbLjlE@G zsTKtniQ{Qt+rr@O%J?Nr$e(k3SPREENbI^VV-7rWpRx41FaN88%+OaN1u_eM0Z_&f zcR&14J|S*+aJ7^fKKi#e0{r4#tIgCD+L~1(dVy_(osl)g-v#)P^&sYU@ED;OIin}m zkJ3Qt&=8p?b?nIUzD@5@tkU7xtpsVX5NJhlXn0Kq%?M1wYYM+61g;y6-r#W`9=peD z)%h}!ROBN_?WLsr&Um~%0KbHWj;)yv32cT|-R%A5%*>s>3HZdusYCzo{GI=O;Ot+& z>e{M63j`J!2Xmk&sU9oohfJaY0*jip_lFn2!HdA6MXJX}%0bHZ(WvU^2>NLJhv2IE zPY(;nkJ>*D)IT+GQawR&P7X;vK0Y2%UUnWHUM_JCHa1>9Nmf=)F%D4y)C)g_kE zElB)Hs}rYe?nOBw{=Ej_LK;C~^UljSqfcJMZS@8KSTx}EbAm0naffwL=) zvP>0@XiqgHlAOEudn9#{IXxSBw0J^foG68amsV5>#+Q7te%ZW*s?lf)UGW^N1bA^R zgc-+SikF zql1{H%zb&v^5%U(b}-JK9D_RI{z0pTPP<5h4A75Vxumg3K?N*dO_+GcxwEZcB?RgF z0z_mec;{ec{X~|KozheGs5i@@y-?`WySzA@OoU5DKWkKV7D6bWK{87P;X6FZ!Zi+4 zRvADoc+ES!K-4{LVw05Wp*To=7l__uMzLrUZXC$wVa(k%N!<=$)fGhk{M0J|+-gl4%ds$a-?*Y7yAF7W~@xZnG4WD;FLCN3b)kKF|X R9xh&X4g@MH2_;E{{|5uBf)fA$ literal 0 HcmV?d00001 diff --git a/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.tex b/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.tex new file mode 100644 index 0000000..74bf182 --- /dev/null +++ b/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-randr_letter.tex @@ -0,0 +1,151 @@ +\documentclass[12pt,letterpaper]{article} + +\usepackage[T1]{ fontenc} +\usepackage[utf8x]{ inputenc} +\usepackage{graphicx} +\usepackage[usenames,dvipsnames]{xcolor} +\usepackage[breaklinks]{hyperref} + +\hypersetup{colorlinks=true, linkcolor=Black, citecolor=Black, filecolor=Blue, + urlcolor=Blue, unicode=true} + +\usepackage[english]{babel} + +\usepackage[font=footnotesize,labelfont=bf]{caption} +\usepackage[margin=0.8in]{geometry} +\usepackage{parskip} + +\begin{document} +\title{Revision Summary for ``Remixing as a Pathway to Computational Thinking''} +\author{} +\date{} +\maketitle + +First, we want to thank all three reviewers and the AC for their thoughtful and constructive feedback. We are glad that the reviewers found our work relevant and interesting. We have read the reviews carefully, taken the feedback seriously, and made quite a number of revisions to our manuscript in response. We have attempted to address every issue raised in the reviews we received. We feel our paper is much stronger as result. In this document, we describe the changes we have made. + +\section{Effect Size (AC, R1, R2)} + +The most important issue raised by reviewers was around our inadequate discussion of effect size -- especially given the large size of our data set. Comments included: + +\begin{quote} + The biggest concern was small effect size, so you might address this issue further in limitations or discussion. (AC) + + I'm slightly concerned that the effect size is small. Papers with a large $n$ and small effect size are worrisome -- does this really mean much? (R1) + + Unfortunately, while the analysis confirms the authors' initial hypotheses, with statistical significance (as you might expect from a sample of this size), the effect sizes were quite marginal (as the authors acknowledge themselves) \ldots + Still, the analysis does give initial confirmatory evidence that + remixing is correlated with learning, and contributes methods that + could be built in. For instance, they might be applied in more + focused contexts (without coloring contests), or more formalized + educational interventions, where we larger effect sizes might be + observed. (R2) +\end{quote} + +We have made several changes to address this concern. First, we have made several small changes to our results section to clarify our reporting, and interpretation, of effect sizes. Second, we have added a full paragraph to the discussion entirely focused on the size of our effects. + +In this new paragraph, we do several things. First, we discuss how considering \emph{Downloads} might affect our interpretation of effect size (see below). Second, as suggested by R2, we point out that small effect sizes may, in part, reflect the informal and unfocused nature of Scratch. To sharpen this point and to suggest ways that designers might support ``high value'' remixing, we add references to work by Brennan on formal learning environments in Scratch, to Cheliotis and Yew on how contests can shape and incentivize remixing in informal environments, and to Roque on how Scratch itself has tried to support ``high value'' remixing through focused interventions in the form of ``collab camps.'' We agree with R2 that effects may be much higher in contexts like these when designers leave the quality and quantity of remixing less up to chance than the designers of Scratch have done. + +\begin{quote} +Please remove the word "strong" from the first sentence of the discussion section. The effect sizes are small, and that isn't really "strong" support in my view. (R1) +\end{quote} + +We have removed the word ``strong'' from the first sentence of the discussion. We also carefully edited the rest of the paper and removed several other similar qualifiers. We overstated our findings and we apologize. + +\section{Robustness Checks (R2)} + +R2 suggested that we report more detail on our robustness checks, especially our results on copy and pasting: + +\begin{quote} + In the limitations section, the authors discuss copy \& pasting as a + shallow demonstration of CT concept in de novo projects. Perhaps + they should include the results of this adjustment in the results + section. I would also be curious to know the precise extent of copy + \& pasting that they detected. (R2) +\end{quote} + +As suggested, we have reported the range of copy and pasted projects (i.e., 2-15\%) in the text of the manuscript. + +We considered including the full results of robustness checks for both this test and our stricter model of parallelism but concluded that the addition of 1-2 pages of results with identical implications was hard to justify in a paper that was already 12 pages long. + +Instead, we have created an appendix to the document that we have included as supplementary material. In it, we include detailed data on the extent of copying and pasting as well as a version of Table 4 that reflects this adjustment. Although it was not requested, we also included results from our robustness check that limits our analysis to in-sprite parallelism. + +If our paper is accepted, we plan to publish this as an online supplement in the ACM Digital Archive. If this is not possible, we will publish our results in our library's institutional archive and include a link to this archival copy in the text of the camera ready version of our manuscript. + +\section{Expanded Interpretation of Results (R2)} + +R2 suggested that we should improve our interpretation of the controls used in our models and pointed to examples of under-explained variables: + +\begin{quote} + More explanation about some the results would be helpful, since some + of them ran against my expectations or intuition. For example, why + remixes have such a strong negative association with particular + concepts (much more negative than the remixes w/ concepts was + positive), and why Downloads is predicted to moderate the effects of + remixing. (R2) +\end{quote} + +We have made a series of changes to improve our discussion and interpretation of controls. We expanded upon and added a paragraph to the part of our results section that discusses controls. In particular, we interpret the effects of \emph{Comments} (mixed in sign between our two sets of models) and \emph{Remixes} (as suggested by R2). In terms of the latter, we suggest that we would not expect a positive effect because remixing projects that do not involve a concept seems unlikely to increase the likelihood that a particular concept will be used and that we believe that the negative effect associated with these estimates, although not anticipated, may be explained by social forms of remixing like coloring contests that are imperfectly controlled for by \emph{Total Blocks}. + +\subsection{Discussion of Downloads (R2)} + +Although downloads were only mentioned briefly in R2's review, we concluded that our interpretation of the measures pointed to a major area for improvement in our manuscript and we have made several changes to improve interpretation of our results in this regard. + +% In Scratch 1.4 (the version analyzed in this paper) downloading was the only way for users to view the code of projects and is a necessary step toward remixing. Because it happens every time a project is remixed, it will be positively correlated and its inclusion will likely explain some of the variation explained by remixing. We include both Models 2 and 3 because there is conceptual overlap between downloading and remixing among theorists. Manovich, for example, clearly argues that reading something and becoming inspired \emph{is remixing} and this form of learning is part of what Papert would call ``appropriation.'' We have made a number of changes to clarify our interpretation in these senses. + +We have completely rewritten and added to the paragraph on downloads in our \emph{Data and Measures} section in order to emphasize that downloading reflects the only way that users can look inside projects and that downloading has strong conceptual overlap with remixing. We point out that Manovich clearly argues that reading something and becoming inspired constitutes a form of remixing and that learning through downloading is part of what Papert calls ``appropriation.'' + +We have also added several sentences to our \emph{Results} section explaining why we predict a moderating effect and explicitly interpreting the size of the coefficient associating with \emph{Downloads} in M3. We also reflect on the pattern of results for downloads in the end of that section. Finally, we refer to our results for downloading in the new paragraph on effect size we have added to our \emph{Discussion} section. + +\subsection{Concept-by-Concept Interpretation of Results for H2 (R2)} + +R2 expressed some dissatisfaction with the lack of insight from concept-by-concept comparisons: + +\begin{quote} + In addition, I was hopeful for insights from analyzing the data on a + concept-by-concept level, but there was little gained in comparing + and interpreting the different concepts, given the similar but + marginal effect sizes. (R2) +\end{quote} + +% https://github.com/makoshark/scratch-remixlearning/blob/c6708a4cb3ad02bb7055f902982a11cde45dbe70/paper/appropriation-cscw2016.Rnw#L437 + +Like R2, we would have also loved results that showed more variation in effect size between concepts. Of course, the results are what they are and we are playing the hand we were dealt. That said, reflecting on R2's comment led us to conclude that we could do better in this regard. Toward that end, we noted that, in general, lower estimates were associated with CT concepts that had lower uptake in Scratch. We have pointed this out and suggested that while it is difficult to draw clear conclusions from this, this phenomena may point to a general difficulty in understanding or learning these CT concepts, at least within Scratch. + +\section{Stylistic Improvements (AC, R2, R3)} + +Finally, we made a series of stylistic improvements to our manuscript. + +As suggested by the AC, we fixed the references section to use an up-to-date style template so that it matches the new ACM guidelines. We have fixed all of the typos pointed out by R2 and fixed the reference to Figure 4 as suggested by R3. We have carefully proofread the paper to try to eliminate other errors. If accepted, we will have the paper proofread by a professional before we submit the camera-ready copy. + + +We thank the reviewers and the AC for all the time and energy they have spent on our paper. We believe our manuscript is much better shape as a result. + +% The following typographical errors were fixed: + +% Item +% Reviewers’ comments +% Responses +% Typo +% Empirical Setting: "(though *\_\_\_* are more granular)" (R2) added “blocks” +% Typo +% Data and Measures: "...we include a control for the number of comments receive by *an* user" (R2) +% changed to “a” +% Typo +% Limitations: "In line with *out* expectations..." (R2) +% changed to “our” +% Typo +% Discussion: "Although our results *provides* evidence..." (R2) +% changed to “provide” + +% \begin{quote} +% I looked in vain for any weaknesses that might undermine confidence +% in the paper's claims or results. Finally, I found one!! I think. In +% the Results section, paragraph 4, you said you showed plots for two +% prototypical users in "Table 4," whereas I think you mean here +% "Figure 4." There. Don't say R3 didn't contribute anything of value… +% (R3) +% \end{quote} + +\end{document} + +% LocalWords: collab novo Manovich diff --git a/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-reviews_round1.txt b/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-reviews_round1.txt new file mode 100644 index 0000000..363d976 --- /dev/null +++ b/cscw_changelogs/2016-remixing_learning/remixing_learning-CSCW2016-reviews_round1.txt @@ -0,0 +1,265 @@ +------------------------ Submission 423, Review 4 ------------------------ + +Title: Remixing as a Pathway to Computational Thinking + +Reviewer: AC +Overall rating: 4 (scale is 1..5; 5 is best) +Reviewer expertise: 4 (scale is 1..4; 4 = "Expert") + +Contribution and Criteria for Evaluation + + This paper empirically examines "remixing," or reuse and modification of + others' solutions, in the context of learning coding concepts using MIT's + Scratch environment for young people. Several dependent measures showed + improved and deep learning by remixers. + +Expertise + + 4 (Expert) + +Formatting and Reference Issues + + The CSCW formatting of references has changed. Please take a look at the + new template (links to Word and Latex templates are available at + http://cscw.acm.org/2016/submit/papers.php) and make the necessary + changes to your reference section. + + +First Round Overall Recommendation + + 4 (Probably acceptable (with minor modifications)) + +First Round Review (if needed) + + + +Coordinator's First-Round Report to Authors + + The reviewers agree that your study is well planned, the results are + interesting, and the paper is well written -- and so they have very few + recommendations for improvement. + + The biggest concern was small effect size, so you might address this + issue further in limitations or discussion. + + It might also be good to expand your discussion to talk about other + learning contexts in which remixing might be beneficial. This is an + opportunity to expand and is not necessary. + + The reference section needs to be reformatted according to the new + guidelines. + + Otherwise, this paper is completely good to go! Congratulations and + thanks for participating in CSCW! + + + + + +------------------------ Submission 423, Review 1 ------------------------ + +Title: Remixing as a Pathway to Computational Thinking + +Overall rating: 4 (scale is 1..5; 5 is best) +Reviewer expertise: 2 (scale is 1..4; 2 = "Passing Knowledge") + +Contribution and Criteria for Evaluation + + This paper analyzes log file data from Scratch to show that remix + activity contributes to learning programming constructs. + +Expertise + + 2 (Passing Knowledge) + +Assessment of the Paper + + + + As the authors point out, the decision of the Scratch designers to so + strongly support remixing is by no means obvious. As a result, this + analysis of whether remixing is educational valuable is significant. + + This paper is well written and careful. I’m generally convinced by its + main point. I’m slightly concerned that the effect size is small. + Papers with a large n and small effect size are worrisome—does this + really mean much? It helps that the authors have gone to great effort to + detail limitations of their work and discuss them clearly. + + I’m not familiar with some of the statistical tests used in this work. + It’s important that someone with experience with all these tests check + the paper’s stats. + + +Requested Revisions + + Please remove the word "strong" from the first sentence of the discussion + section. The effect sizes are small, and that isn't really "strong" + support in my view. + +Formatting and Reference Issues + + +First Round Overall Recommendation + + 4 (Probably acceptable (with minor modifications)) + + +------------------------ Submission 423, Review 2 ------------------------ + +Title: Remixing as a Pathway to Computational Thinking + +Overall rating: 4 (scale is 1..5; 5 is best) +Reviewer expertise: 2 (scale is 1..4; 2 = "Passing Knowledge") + +Contribution and Criteria for Evaluation + + The intended contribution of this paper is a large-scale quantitative + analysis of whether remixing leads to learning, both broadly (repertoire) + and narrowly (use to CT concepts). To be considered a meaningful + contribution, this analysis should report significant effects of remixing + on both repertoire size and concept usage, and an interpretation of these + results. + +Expertise + + 2 (Passing Knowledge) + +Assessment of the Paper + + The paper is well-written and organized. The authors do an excellent job + introducing the context and summarizing relevant literature from both + theoretical and empirical perspective. They make a compelling case that a + large-scale quantitative analysis of a Scratch data would complement + earlier qualitative studies that have been conducted in more limited + contexts. In particular, the longitudinal nature of the dataset allows + the researchers to explore the long-term learning effects of remixing + practice. + + The data collection and analysis have been conducted with care, for + instance controlling for a number of potential confounds. Examining the + content and metadata of a user's projects over time, and mapping + computational concepts to specific programming constructs, seems like a + promising approach to handling this volume and type of data. + + Unfortunately, while the analysis confirms the authors' initial + hypotheses, with statistical significance (as you might expect from a + sample of this size), the effect sizes were quite marginal (as the + authors acknowledge themselves). In addition, I was hopeful for insights + from analyzing the data on a concept-by-concept level, but there was + little gained in comparing and interpreting the different concepts, given + the similar but marginal effect sizes. + + Still, the analysis does give initial confirmatory evidence that remixing + is correlated with learning, and contributes methods that could be built + in. For instance, they might be applied in more focused contexts (without + coloring contests), or more formalized educational interventions, where + we larger effect sizes might be observed. + +Requested Revisions + + More explanation about some the results would be helpful, since some of + them ran against my expectations or intuition. For example, why remixes + have such a strong negative association with particular concepts (much + more negative than the remixes w/ concepts was positive), and why + Downloads is predicted to moderate the effects of remixing. + + In the limitations section, the authors discuss copy & pasting as a + shallow demonstration of CT concept in de novo projects. Perhaps they + should include the results of this adjustment in the results section. I + would also be curious to know the precise extent of copy & pasting that + they detected. + + There were very few typos that I caught: + + Empirical Setting: "(though *___* are more granular)" + + Data and Measures: "...we include a control for the number of comments + receive by *an* user" + + Limitations: "In line with *out* expectations..." + + Discussion: "Although our results *provides* evidence..." + +Formatting and Reference Issues + + +First Round Overall Recommendation + + 4 (Probably acceptable (with minor modifications)) + + +------------------------ Submission 423, Review 3 ------------------------ + +Title: Remixing as a Pathway to Computational Thinking + +Reviewer: AC-Reviewer +Overall rating: 5 (scale is 1..5; 5 is best) +Reviewer expertise: 3 (scale is 1..4; 3 = "Knowledgeable") + +Contribution and Criteria for Evaluation + + This paper provides a quantitative examination of whether there is + evidence that remixing is a viable approach to learning programming. The + paper is a well-executed example of using regression models to test + research hypotheses and providing a thoughtful and well-developed + rationale and discussion of the work. + + The main criteria for evaluating this type of contribution is both the + quality of the quantitative test, and (for the CSCW audience) the quality + of the rationale and explanation/discussion of results surrounding the + empirical data. + +Expertise + + 3 (Knowledgeable) + +Assessment of the Paper + + This is a beautifully written and well-presented paper examining whether + the remixing philosophy that underlies the Scratch community's approach + to learning programming is actually effective, in line with the + reputation it enjoys in the social computing literature. The authors look + at a huge dataset of Scratch programming projects, and describe a careful + and well-executed approach to two fundamental hypotheses: 1) that more + remixing is associated with more growth in a learner's repertoire of + Scratch programming blocks, and 2) that a learner who has remixed more + projects containing a particular computational thinking concepts will be + more likely to incorporate those concepts into a future de novo project. + The degree of care and thought put into testing both of these hypotheses + with an extremely large dataset is evident throughout the paper. + + Related to this is the excellent writing of the paper, which is + intimately tied to the explanation of the research and its results. The + authors lead readers through their process and thinking step by step, + from cleansing of the data, to sharing the exact models and the rationale + behind various control variables that were added as the exploratory + models were built up, and to the results, and the limitations or cautions + on the results. The authors have a very nice way of connecting their work + thoroughly with prior research ("We are also inspired by work by ...") + and pointing out along the way findings of particular interest, or that + inform in new ways on previously established findings. + + I looked in vain for any weaknesses that might undermine confidence in + the paper's claims or results. Finally, I found one!! I think. In the + Results section, paragraph 4, you said you showed plots for two + prototypical users in "Table 4," whereas I think you mean here "Figure + 4." There. Don't say R3 didn't contribute anything of value... + + Seriously, this is a model paper that gets everything right, that has the + added bonus of making a highly quantitative approach understandable by a + wide range of CSCW readers. I look forward to seeing it in the program. + +Requested Revisions + + Um, change "Table 4" to "Figure 4." + +Formatting and Reference Issues + + The references are not in the new format, but since I really dislike the + new format... + +First Round Overall Recommendation + + 5 (Definitely acceptable (ready as-is)) +